2023 Audi S3 Review: Is It Still Worth Buying?

The 2023 Audi S3 remains a compelling choice for luxury performance enthusiasts, delivering 306 horsepower from its turbocharged 2.0-liter engine, sophisticated Quattro all-wheel drive, and premium interior appointments at a starting price of $47,895. While newer model years offer incremental improvements, the 2023 S3 provides excellent value with proven technology, strong safety ratings from IIHS, and the refined driving experience that defines Audi’s entry-level S model^[1][2].

Despite competition from the Volkswagen Golf R and Mercedes-AMG CLA35, the 2023 S3 distinguishes itself through superior interior quality, comprehensive standard equipment, and Audi’s reputation for engineering excellence, making it an attractive option for buyers prioritizing luxury refinement over pure performance value^[3][4].

2023 Audi S3 Overview and Key Features

What’s New for 2023

The 2023 model year brought refined enhancements to maintain the S3’s competitive edge in the luxury compact performance segment. The 306 horsepower 2.0L turbocharged engine serves as the centerpiece of the S3’s appeal, delivering substantial power through advanced turbocharging technology that minimizes lag while maximizing efficiency^[1][2].

Key mechanical improvements include:

• Seven-speed dual-clutch automatic transmission with rapid shifts and multiple driving modes for different conditions^[4][1]
• Quattro all-wheel drive system standard providing enhanced traction and stability across all weather conditions^[5][1]
• Minor updates: adaptive cruise control and wireless charging added as standard or optional equipment depending on trim level^[6][5]

The 2023 S3 benefits from Audi’s continuous refinement philosophy, incorporating lessons learned from previous generations while maintaining the essential character that appeals to performance-oriented luxury buyers.

Model Lineup and Pricing Structure

The 2023 S3 offers three distinct trim levels designed to accommodate different budgets and feature preferences. According to Car and Driver and TrueCar pricing analysis, the structure provides clear value progression^[1][5]:

Trim Level	Original MSRP	Current Market Price	Key Features
Premium	$47,895	$39,495-$43,400	Base S3 features, Quattro AWD, sport seats
Premium Plus	~$51,395	$38,419-$43,600	Driver assistance, wireless charging, memory seats
Prestige	$54,595	$47,251-$48,593	Bang & Olufsen audio, luxury appointments

Both Sportback and Sedan body style options are available across the lineup, with the Sportback offering slightly more cargo versatility for buyers prioritizing practicality^[7][8]. The choice between body styles primarily affects aesthetics and cargo access rather than performance capabilities.

Target Market and Positioning

The S3 specifically targets entry-level luxury performance buyers who desire Audi’s premium brand prestige without stepping up to more expensive RS models^[5][1]. This positioning makes it particularly appealing to professionals and enthusiasts seeking a capable daily driver that doesn’t compromise on luxury or performance.

Competition with Golf R and Mercedes-AMG CLA35 intensifies in this segment, with each offering different approaches to performance and value^[9][1]. The S3’s competitive advantage lies in its comprehensive luxury approach, advanced technology integration, and brand prestige rather than pure performance per dollar.

Daily driver enthusiasts seeking premium features represent the core demographic, as the S3 successfully balances spirited performance with comfort and refinement needed for regular commuting^[2][5]. According to automotive industry analysis from Autvex, this segment continues growing as buyers seek vehicles excelling in multiple areas rather than specializing in just one.

Performance and Engine Specifications

Powertrain Details

At the heart of the 2023 S3 lies a sophisticated 2.0L TFSI turbocharged four-cylinder engine that exemplifies modern automotive engineering excellence^[10][1]. The powerplant generates 306 horsepower at 5,450 rpm and 295 lb-ft of torque at 3,000 rpm, providing strong mid-range performance suitable for both aggressive driving and efficient cruising^[2][1].

The engine incorporates several advanced technologies:

• Direct injection for improved fuel efficiency and power delivery
• Variable valve timing optimizing performance across the rev range
• Intercooled turbocharging with minimal lag characteristics
• Aluminum construction reducing weight and enhancing thermal management^[10][1]

The seven-speed dual-clutch transmission provides nearly instantaneous gear changes while offering both automatic convenience and manual control through paddle shifters, making it well-suited for both daily driving and spirited performance^[4][1].

Acceleration and Speed Metrics

Professional testing reveals impressive performance figures positioning the S3 competitively within its segment. 0-60 mph acceleration occurs in 4.3-4.5 seconds, demonstrating the effectiveness of the Quattro all-wheel drive system in translating power to forward motion^[2][1].

Additional performance benchmarks include:

• Quarter-mile: 12.9 seconds at 108 mph indicating strong sustained acceleration^[1]
• Top speed: 155 mph (electronically limited) providing ample high-speed capability^[11][2]
• Rolling acceleration: approximately 5.2 seconds (5-60 mph) for real-world passing situations

These figures place the S3 ahead of many direct competitors and demonstrate that the relatively small displacement doesn’t compromise performance when combined with advanced turbocharging and all-wheel drive.

Handling and Dynamics

The S3’s handling characteristics benefit significantly from Quattro all-wheel drive as standard equipment, providing confident traction in various road conditions while enhancing cornering stability^[5][1]. The system’s intelligent torque distribution helps minimize understeer while maintaining predictable handling characteristics.

Sport-tuned suspension for enhanced handling includes specially calibrated dampers and springs that balance performance with comfort^[12][1]. Launch control system availability allows maximum acceleration from standstill while protecting drivetrain components^[13][14].

According to Autoweb’s road test analysis, the S3 delivers “taut, responsive, and overall delightful” driving characteristics that reject the isolation common in many modern luxury sedans^[15].

Interior Design and Technology Features

Cabin Layout and Materials

The 2023 S3 interior showcases premium materials and sport seats that justify its luxury positioning while providing support needed during spirited driving^[4][5]. S-specific styling elements and badging distinguish it from regular A3 models through unique trim pieces, seat designs, and instrumentation^[6][4].

Interior highlights include:

• Nappa leather seating surfaces with quilted inserts and sport bolsters
• Genuine aluminum or carbon fiber trim depending on trim level and options
• Three-zone automatic climate control for individualized comfort settings
• Flat-bottom steering wheel and illuminated door jamb scuff plates

Build quality assessment and finish consistently receive praise in professional reviews, with tight panel gaps, solid-feeling controls, and materials that feel substantial and durable^[9][4]. The cabin layout prioritizes driver engagement while maintaining luxury comfort expectations.

Infotainment and Connectivity

Technology integration centers around a 10.1-inch touchscreen display that avoids the aftermarket appearance common in many modern vehicles^[9][5]. The Audi Virtual Cockpit digital instrument cluster replaces traditional analog gauges with a customizable interface showing navigation, performance data, and vehicle information^[9][5].

Standard connectivity features include:

• Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration for seamless smartphone connectivity^[5][9]
• Wireless charging pad on Premium Plus and Prestige trims
• Bang & Olufsen premium audio system on higher trim levels
• MMI software interface with intuitive menu structures

The system’s design prioritizes usability while driving, with logical controls and physical buttons for frequently used functions like climate control and audio volume.

Space and Practicality

Despite its compact exterior dimensions, the S3 accommodates five passengers with reasonable comfort for front and rear occupants^[14][4]. However, cargo space measures just 8.3 cubic feet, which is notably small compared to larger luxury sedans^[4][1].

Practical considerations include:

• Adequate front seat comfort with supportive sport seats and sufficient adjustment range
• Tight rear legroom that accommodates adults on shorter trips but may feel cramped for taller passengers
• Limited trunk capacity requiring careful packing for extended travel
• 40-20-40 split-folding rear seats to expand cargo capacity when needed

Rear seat comfort and accessibility varies between body styles, with the Sportback offering easier entry and more flexible cargo loading^[4][9]. The S3 works best as a four-person vehicle with occasional fifth passenger capability.

2023 Audi S3 vs Key Competitors

S3 vs Volkswagen Golf R

The comparison between the S3 and Golf R represents one of the most common cross-shopping scenarios in the compact performance segment. Power comparison reveals 306hp vs 315hp, with the Golf R holding a slight advantage in raw output^[13][9]. However, real-world performance differences are minimal due to the S3’s superior drivetrain calibration and transmission programming.

Interior quality and luxury features strongly favor the S3, offering significantly better materials, more refined design, and additional comfort amenities^[16][9]. The price difference and value proposition shows the S3 commanding approximately $5,000-8,000 more than comparably equipped Golf R models^[17][18].

Specification	2023 Audi S3	2023 VW Golf R
Horsepower	306 hp	315 hp
Starting Price	$47,895	~$43,000
Interior Materials	Premium leather/aluminum	Sport cloth/plastic
Brand Positioning	Luxury performance	Performance value

S3 vs Mercedes-AMG CLA35/A35

Performance metrics comparison shows similar acceleration figures between the S3 and Mercedes alternatives, though each delivers power differently^[13][1]. The S3’s linear power delivery contrasts with Mercedes emphasis on low-end torque and aggressive tuning characteristics.

Technology and safety features comparisons reveal the S3’s strength in user interface design and overall system integration^[9][5]. Ownership costs and reliability factors tend to favor the Audi due to more reasonable maintenance requirements and better long-term durability records^[5][9].

S3 vs BMW M235i Gran Coupe

Driving dynamics and handling characteristics show the S3 offering more balanced performance due to its Quattro system versus BMW’s front-wheel-drive-based platform^[12][1]. Fuel economy comparison analysis favors the S3 with better overall efficiency ratings^[2][1].

Long-term value retention prospects from Kelley Blue Book analysis suggest the S3 maintains competitive resale values within the segment, with current trade-in values ranging from $29,630-$39,330 depending on condition^[8][5].

Fuel Economy and Efficiency Analysis

EPA Ratings and Real-World Testing

The 2023 S3 achieves EPA ratings of 23 mpg city, 32 mpg highway, and 26 combined, representing excellent efficiency for a performance-oriented luxury sedan^[1][2]. These figures surpass many competitors in the segment and demonstrate the effectiveness of Audi’s turbocharged four-cylinder approach.

Premium fuel requirements and recommendations are necessary to achieve rated performance and efficiency figures, with the engine calibrated for 91-octane gasoline^[2][1]. Real-world efficiency results from testing consistently meet or exceed EPA estimates, with Autoweb achieving 32 mpg average and up to 40 mpg highway cruising^[2][5].

Highway efficiency particularly impresses, making the S3 well-suited for longer trips despite its performance orientation and compact size.

Fuel Costs and Operating Expenses

Annual fuel cost estimates for average drivers suggest approximately $2,200-2,500 for 12,000 miles of mixed driving based on current premium fuel prices^[2][5]. Comparison to hybrid alternatives in segment reveals the S3’s limitations in pure efficiency terms, though no direct hybrid competitors offer comparable performance characteristics^[5][2].

Highway touring range and capability benefits from excellent fuel economy, providing over 400 miles range on a full tank during highway cruising^[2][5]. This makes the S3 practical for long-distance travel while maintaining performance capabilities.

Environmental Impact Considerations

Emissions ratings and eco-friendliness place the S3 in the moderate category for environmental impact, with EPA environmental scores reflecting typical performance for turbocharged gasoline engines^[1][5]. Turbo four-cylinder efficiency benefits include reduced displacement compared to larger naturally aspirated engines while maintaining power output^[1][2].

Carbon footprint versus larger engines shows the S3 performing reasonably well within its class, though buyers prioritizing maximum environmental consciousness might consider hybrid alternatives^[5][2]. The balance between performance and efficiency represents a compromise appealing to enthusiasts wanting moderate environmental consciousness.

Reliability and Common Issues Analysis

Known Problems and Concerns

While the 2023 model benefits from ongoing refinements, certain recurring issues affect the S3 platform that potential buyers should understand. Coolant leaks from thermostat housing have been reported in some cases, particularly in vehicles with higher mileage or inadequate maintenance^[19][20].

Turbocharger issues and maintenance needs occasionally include wastegate problems or carbon buildup, though proper maintenance significantly reduces these concerns^[20][19]. Electrical system malfunctions and glitches can affect infotainment connectivity and various comfort features, with some owners reporting MMI system connectivity issues^[21][22].

Consumer Reports data indicates average reliability expectations for the Audi A3 platform, with the 2023 model having two NHTSA recalls related to safety systems^[23].

Maintenance Requirements and Costs

Service intervals and routine maintenance follow Audi’s flexible maintenance schedule, typically requiring major services every 10,000 miles or annually^[24][20]. According to CarEdge analysis, the S3 will cost approximately $9,755 for maintenance and repairs during its first 10 years, which beats the luxury sedan average by $35^[25].

Common wear items and replacement schedules include:

• Brake pads and rotors: $800-1,200 per axle for performance components
• Tires: $1,200-1,600 for a set of four performance tires
• Oil changes: $150-200 using synthetic oil and genuine filters
• DSG service: $400-500 every 40,000 miles for transmission maintenance^[26][20]

Haldex AWD system maintenance needs require periodic fluid changes and system inspections to ensure optimal performance and longevity^[20][21]. This service typically costs $300-400 and should be performed every 40,000 miles according to Audi specifications.

Warranty Coverage and Support

Factory warranty terms and coverage include 4 years/50,000 miles of bumper-to-bumper protection and 4 years/50,000 miles of powertrain coverage^[1][5]. This coverage is competitive within the luxury segment though shorter than some mainstream manufacturers offer.

Extended warranty options and recommendations are available through Audi Care and third-party providers, extending coverage for up to 8 years or 100,000 miles^[27][5]. Given the S3’s performance orientation and potential repair costs, extended coverage may be worthwhile for long-term ownership.

Certified pre-owned program benefits include additional warranty coverage, roadside assistance, and thorough inspection processes for qualifying vehicles^[26][5]. This program provides peace of mind for buyers considering slightly used examples.

Pricing and Value Analysis

MSRP and Trim Level Breakdown

The 2023 S3’s original pricing structure positioned it strategically within the compact luxury performance segment. Premium trim originally started at $47,895, offering core S performance features and standard Quattro all-wheel drive^[1][5]. Premium Plus at mid-tier pricing added significant value through driver assistance technologies and convenience features^[5][1]. Prestige originally at $54,595 topped the range with premium audio, luxury appointments, and advanced technology^[1].

Current market conditions show significant depreciation, with used examples ranging from $35,857-$48,593 depending on trim level and condition, representing substantial savings over original MSRP^[28].

Options and Popular Packages

Black Optic package and styling upgrades represent popular cosmetic enhancements adding distinctive visual appeal^[6][1]. Technology package and premium features include Bang & Olufsen sound system, advanced driver assistance, and enhanced infotainment capabilities^[5][1].

Performance and convenience option groups include:

• 19-inch wheel upgrades: Enhanced styling and performance handling
• Premium paint colors: Distinctive exterior finishes including Turbo Blue and Python Yellow
• Interior packages: Upgraded materials and luxury appointments
• Sport exhaust system: Enhanced sound and modest performance gains^[6][5]

Market Value and Depreciation

Current market pricing trends show the 2023 S3 experiencing typical luxury car depreciation, with Kelley Blue Book reporting current trade-in values ranging from $29,630-$39,330^[8][5]. Lease vs buy financial analysis generally favored leasing for the 2023 model year, though current used pricing makes purchasing more attractive^[27][5].

Resale value predictions and factors suggest the S3 will continue moderate depreciation typical of luxury performance vehicles, with factors like maintenance history, mileage, and condition significantly affecting values^[26][5]. According to automotive market analysis from read more at 2025 Audi s3, the luxury compact segment shows stable demand patterns.

Buying Guide and Shopping Tips

Which Trim Level to Choose

Premium vs Premium Plus feature comparison represents the most critical decision point for S3 buyers^[1][5]. The Premium Plus’s additional cost included driver assistance features, wireless charging, and premium amenities that significantly enhanced daily usability and safety.

Must-have options and packages recommendations depend on individual priorities, but most automotive experts recommended the Premium Plus trim with select appearance packages^[6][5]. Sportback vs Sedan decision factors primarily affect cargo space and styling preference^[7][8]. The Sportback offers more versatile loading capability, while the Sedan provides traditional luxury sedan aesthetics.

New vs Used Buying Considerations

2023 model year advantages and improvements included refined technology interfaces and enhanced driver assistance features that differentiated it from earlier generations^[6][5]. Certified pre-owned alternatives and benefits from 2021-2022 model years offered similar performance with significant cost savings^[26][5].

Depreciation timing and value considerations suggest that current used 2023 examples provide optimal value by offering latest-generation features while avoiding steep initial depreciation^[26][5]. Market analysis shows 2023 models currently trading at $8,000-15,000 below original MSRP.

Inspection and Maintenance Preparation

Pre-purchase inspection checklist items should include thorough examination of turbocharger operation, DSG transmission performance, and electrical system functionality^[20][26]. Service history verification importance cannot be overstated, as proper maintenance significantly affects long-term reliability and performance^[20][26].

Common problem areas to examine include:

• Coolant system components for signs of leaks or temperature irregularities
• Turbocharger operation during test drives across various RPM ranges
• Electrical systems including infotainment connectivity and driver assistance features
• Suspension components for wear appropriate to mileage and driving conditions^[19][21]

Key Takeaways

• Strong performance value: The 306 horsepower turbocharged engine and Quattro all-wheel drive deliver exceptional performance in the compact luxury segment with 0-60 mph in 4.3-4.5 seconds
• Significant depreciation advantage: Current used 2023 models trade for $8,000-15,000 below original MSRP, providing excellent value for latest-generation features
• Fuel efficiency leadership: 26 mpg combined EPA rating with real-world results often exceeding 30 mpg makes it surprisingly economical for a performance sedan
• Safety recognition: IIHS Top Safety Pick+ award demonstrates Audi’s commitment to comprehensive crash protection and advanced safety technologies
• Maintenance cost awareness: Annual maintenance averaging $725-975 requires budget planning, though costs are competitive within the luxury performance segment
• Premium Plus optimization: The mid-level trim provided the best balance of essential features and value for most buyers during the 2023 model year
• Market timing advantage: Current used car market conditions offer compelling opportunities for buyers seeking luxury performance with proven reliability

The 2023 Audi S3 delivers strong performance with 306 horsepower, premium interior quality, and advanced technology, making it a compelling choice for luxury performance buyers, though potential reliability issues and higher maintenance costs should be carefully considered^[19][5][1]. Its position as Audi’s entry-level S model continues providing access to the brand’s performance heritage while maintaining daily usability that appeals to a broad range of luxury car buyers.

FAQs

References

1. Car and Driver. (2022). 2023 Audi S3 Review, Pricing, and Specs. https://www.caranddriver.com/audi/s3-2023
2. The Drive. (2023). 2023 Audi S3 Review: A Classic Audi for Today. https://www.thedrive.com/car-reviews/2023-audi-s3-review-specs-price-options-impressions
3. Edmunds. (2022). 2023 Audi S3 Review & Ratings. https://www.edmunds.com/audi/s3/2023/
4. U.S. News. (2025). 2023 Audi S3 Review – US News Cars. https://cars.usnews.com/cars-trucks/audi/s3/2023
5. TrueCar. (2023). 2023 Audi S3 Review | Pricing, Trims & Photos. https://www.truecar.com/overview/audi/s3/2023/
6. The Audi Connection. (2023). What You Should Know About the 2023 Audi S3. https://www.theaudiconnection.com/blog/2023/january/24/what-you-should-know-about-the-2023-audi-s3.htm
7. Carsales. (2023). Audi S3 Sportback 2023 Review. https://www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/audi-s3-sportback-2023-review-139050/
8. Carsguide. (2023). Audi S3 2023 Price & Specs. https://www.carsguide.com.au/audi/s3/price/2023
9. Cinch. (2024). Audi S3 vs. Golf R: which hot hatch is better? https://www.cinch.co.uk/guides/choosing-a-car/audi-s3-vs-golf-r
10. Audi Peoria. (2023). 2023 Audi S3. https://www.audipeoria.com/2023-audi-s3-peoria-il.htm
11. U.S. News. (2023). 2023 Audi S3 Performance. https://cars.usnews.com/cars-trucks/audi/s3/2023/performance
12. Autoweb. (2023). 2023 Audi S3 Road Test and Review. https://www.autoweb.com/2023-audi-s3-road-test-and-review
13. What Car. (2021). New Volkswagen Golf R vs Audi S3 vs BMW M135i. https://www.whatcar.com/news/new-volkswagen-golf-r-vs-audi-s3-vs-bmw-m135i/n23134
14. Audipedia. (2023). 2023 Audi S3 Launch Control. https://www.audipeoria.com/2023-audi-s3-peoria-il.htm
15. Autoweb. (2023). 2023 Audi S3 Road Test and Review. https://www.autoweb.com/2023-audi-s3-road-test-and-review
16. Reddit. (2025). Hello, debating on the Golf R vs Audi S3. https://www.reddit.com/r/Golf_R/comments/1mhvez7/hello_debating_on_the_golf_r_vs_audi_s3_what_made/
17. Motor Point. (2025). Volkswagen Golf R vs Audi S3. https://www.motorpoint.co.uk/comparisons/volkswagen-golf-r-vs-audi-s3
18. VW Victoria. (2023). Comparing the 2023 Volkswagen Golf R vs Audi S3 Sedan. https://www.vwvicto.com/new/compare/2023-Volkswagen-Golf_R-vs-2023-Audi-S3_Sedan.html
19. Engine Patrol. (2024). 11 Most Common Audi S3 Problems (Explained). https://enginepatrol.com/audi-s3-common-problems/
20. JXL Performance. (2024). Audi S3 8V Maintenance Guide. https://jxlperformance.co.uk/blogs/s3-8v/audi-s3-8v-maintenance-guide
21. Adelaide Auto Pro. (2024). Common Problems of Audi A3 8Y S3. https://www.adelaideautopro.com.au/post/common-problems-of-audi-a3-8y-s3-a-comprehensive-guide
22. Capital Motor Cars. (2025). Audi A3 Reliability: What Owners Should Expect. https://capitalmotorcars.com/audi-a3-reliability-guide/
23. Consumer Reports. (2023). 2023 Audi A3 Reliability. https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/audi/a3/2023/reliability/
24. JXL Performance. (2024). Audi S3 8V Maintenance Guide. https://jxlperformance.co.uk/blogs/s3-8v/audi-s3-8v-maintenance-guide
25. CarEdge. (2024). Audi S3 Maintenance Costs. https://caredge.com/audi/s3/maintenance
26. JXL Performance. (2024). Audi S3 8V Buying Guide. https://jxlperformance.co.uk/blogs/s3-8v/audi-s3-8v-buying-guide
27. Reddit. (2023). First time Audi owner – requesting maintenance tips. https://www.reddit.com/r/Audi/comments/11hi3hf/first_time_audi_owner_requesting_maintenance_tips/
28. Kelley Blue Book. (2025). 2023 Audi S3 Premium Plus Sedan 4D. https://www.kbb.com/audi/s3/2023/premium-plus-sedan-4d/