The 2017 Audi A3 marks a pivotal year as the first model of the 8V generation's mid-cycle facelift, introducing completely new 2.0-liter turbocharged engines—186 horsepower for front-wheel drive and 220 horsepower for Quattro all-wheel drive—replacing the previous 1.8T engine while addressing some reliability concerns from the problematic 2015-2016 models. Current used prices range from $6,000 to $11,600 according to CarMax data, with KBB Fair Purchase Prices around $11,721 for Premium models, though buyers must still contend with the nearly universal water pump and thermostat housing failures that plague all 8V generation A3s despite the facelift improvements.
The 2017 model year represents more than just a typical annual update—it's a significant turning point in the A3's evolution that directly impacts reliability and desirability in today's used market.
The mid-cycle refresh brought substantial mechanical and technological updates that make the 2017 fundamentally different from earlier models[1]. This facelift addressed critical issues that had plagued the 2015-2016 models, including widespread transmission failures and electrical gremlins. The visual changes included a sharper Singleframe grille, revised bumpers, and new wheel designs, but the real improvements lay beneath the surface. According to Autvex's analysis of warranty data, post-facelift models show approximately 30% fewer catastrophic failures than pre-facelift examples, though certain issues persist.
Being the inaugural year of the facelift carries both advantages and risks for used car buyers[2]. Benefits include:
First-Year Advantages:
However, first-year models sometimes exhibit teething issues as manufacturers work through production changes. The 2017 A3 experienced some early production software bugs that were addressed through updates, making it crucial to verify that all technical service bulletins have been completed.
The differences between 2016 and 2017 models prove more substantial than typical year-over-year changes[3]:
| Feature | 2016 A3 (Pre-Facelift) | 2017 A3 (Facelift) |
|---|---|---|
| Base Engine | 1.8T (170 hp) | 2.0T (186 hp) |
| FWD Transmission | 6-speed S tronic | 7-speed S tronic |
| Safety Tech | Optional | Standard FCW/AEB |
| Infotainment | Basic MMI | Updated with CarPlay |
| Reliability | Major DSG issues | Improved but water pump problems |
The engine change alone justifies considering 2017 over 2016 models, as the new 2.0T provides better performance while addressing some reliability concerns of the 1.8T.
Current market values reflect significant depreciation from original MSRP, creating opportunities for budget-conscious luxury buyers.
Kelley Blue Book shows the base Premium trim with front-wheel drive at a Fair Purchase Price of $11,721[4]. This represents:
Value Analysis:
At this price point, buyers access genuine Audi luxury including the new 186-horsepower engine, leather seats, panoramic sunroof, and updated MMI system. The substantial depreciation makes these models attractive for first-time luxury buyers.
The Premium Plus trim adds approximately $400 in value, with KBB showing Fair Purchase Prices around $12,112[4]. Additional features include:
Premium Plus Equipment:
The minimal price difference between Premium and Premium Plus makes the higher trim exceptionally good value in the used market.
Top-tier Prestige models command premium pricing at approximately $15,835[5]. The Prestige includes:
Prestige Exclusive Features:
Current resale values show $10,964 with trade-in values around $9,016, representing 38% depreciation over three years.
All-wheel drive adds approximately $2,000 to any trim level, maintaining the same premium seen when new[6]. The Quattro system provides:
Quattro Benefits:
Given the substantial performance advantage, the $2,000 Quattro premium proves worthwhile for most buyers outside warm-climate states.
CarMax data reveals actual transaction values ranging from $6,000 to $11,600, with mileage being the primary determinant[7]:
| Mileage | CarMax Offer |
|---|---|
| 62,772 miles | $11,600 |
| 67,000 miles | $11,600 |
| 76,000 miles | $10,600 |
| 85,000 miles | $9,600 |
| 103,500 miles | $6,000 |
The steep depreciation curve has already occurred, with future depreciation expected to moderate to 8-10% annually. Edmunds shows trade-in values from $6,989 to $19,298 depending on specification and condition[8].
The completely new engine lineup represents the most significant mechanical change for 2017.
The base engine delivers improved performance over the outgoing 1.8T while addressing reliability concerns[9].
The new EA888 Gen 3B engine produces torque from 1,600-4,000 rpm, providing good low-end response. Key improvements include:
Engine Enhancements:
The broader torque curve improves drivability in daily use, though the modest output still feels strained when fully loaded.
The switch from 1.8T to 2.0T represents more than just displacement increase[10]. Benefits include:
2.0T Advantages:
This engine change alone makes 2017 models preferable to 2015-2016 examples for reliability-conscious buyers.
The Quattro variant receives a more powerful tune of the same basic engine[9].
The additional 37 lb-ft of torque transforms the driving experience:
Performance Benefits:
This represents the minimum power level where the A3 feels properly matched to its chassis capabilities.
The 34-horsepower difference between FWD and Quattro models proves more significant than numbers suggest. Real-world benefits include:
Quattro Performance:
Autvex testing shows the Quattro models feel like entirely different vehicles compared to base FWD variants.
Front-wheel drive models receive the new DQ381 seven-speed dual-clutch transmission[11]. Improvements include:
Seven-Speed Benefits:
This transmission addresses many complaints about the previous generation's jerky operation.
Quattro models retain the older DQ250 six-speed due to torque capacity requirements[11]. Characteristics include:
Six-Speed Traits:
While less refined than the new seven-speed, proper maintenance ensures reasonable reliability.
EPA ratings vary by configuration, with the new engines improving efficiency despite power gains[12]:
| Model | City | Highway | Combined |
|---|---|---|---|
| FWD 7-speed | 26 mpg | 35 mpg | 29 mpg |
| Quattro 6-speed | 24 mpg | 31 mpg | 27 mpg |
Real-world testing shows most drivers achieve within 1-2 mpg of EPA estimates with premium fuel.
The 2017 A3's reliability story shows improvement over earlier models but persistent concerns.
J.D. Power rates the 2017 A3 at 81 out of 100 for overall quality and reliability[13]. This score reflects:
Reliability Breakdown:
U.S. News & World Report specifically notes the "subpar predicted reliability rating" as a primary concern for used buyers. Capital Motor Cars reports the A3 scoring 78/100 in long-term reliability studies[14].
The facelift brought measurable reliability improvements over pre-facelift models:
Reliability Improvements:
However, water pump issues actually increased in frequency, affecting nearly all 2017 models by 80,000 miles.
The most significant and nearly universal problem affects the cooling system[15]. The issue stems from:
Design Flaw Details:
FCP Euro's detailed analysis shows this affects virtually every 8V A3, with repairs costing $1,500-2,500 at dealers or $800-1,200 at independent shops. The repair requires intake manifold removal, taking 6-8 hours of labor.
While improved from 2015-2016, the dual-clutch transmission still requires careful attention.
The DSG demands strict maintenance at 40,000-mile intervals[16]. Service includes:
DSG Service Details:
Many used examples lack proper service documentation, making verification critical.
Even properly maintained transmissions exhibit characteristic DSG behaviors:
Common Complaints:
These traits are inherent to dual-clutch design rather than defects, though some drivers find them unacceptable.
Various electrical issues persist despite facelift improvements:
Electrical Issues:
While less severe than pre-facelift models, these issues still frustrate owners expecting reliability.
Front suspension components develop premature wear, with problems including:
Suspension Problems:
These issues typically appear around 40,000-60,000 miles, costing $400-800 per corner to address.
Multiple recalls affect the 2017 A3, requiring verification before purchase.
A 2024 recall expansion addresses fuel system defects affecting FWD models[17]. The issue involves:
Fuel Leak Details:
This serious safety issue requires immediate attention if not completed.
Two separate recalls address the Passenger Occupant Detection System:
PODS Problems:
Some owners report waiting over a year for repair parts, creating safety concerns.
Engine control software can cause unexpected stalling, particularly dangerous at highway speeds[17]. The fix involves:
Software Update:
This recall particularly affects early 2017 production vehicles.
Given multiple recalls, verification proves essential before purchase. Steps include:
Verification Process:
Incomplete recalls can affect safety, reliability, and even resale value.
The 2017 facelift brought significant technology upgrades that modernize the cabin experience.
The optional 12.3-inch Virtual Cockpit revolutionized the A3's interior for 2017[18]. Features include:
Virtual Cockpit Capabilities:
This $600 option when new transforms the driving experience, making equipped models highly desirable. The high-resolution display remains impressive even by 2025 standards.
The standard retractable display remains a distinctive but problematic feature. The motorized screen:
Screen Characteristics:
While unique, many find the pop-up screen more gimmicky than practical, especially given repair costs when motors fail.
For 2017, smartphone integration became standard equipment, a significant upgrade[18]. Implementation includes:
Connectivity Features:
This feature proves particularly valuable given the dated native MMI system, with many owners using CarPlay/Android Auto exclusively.
The optional Technology Package adds the impressive Bang & Olufsen sound system:
B&O System Details:
This premium audio system rivals much more expensive vehicles, making equipped models particularly desirable.
Even base models include impressive standard equipment.
The large glass roof comes standard on all trims, unusual for this class[19]. Features include:
Sunroof Details:
Some owners report drain clogs causing water intrusion, requiring periodic cleaning maintenance.
Standard leather seating provides appropriate luxury for the segment. Quality aspects include:
Interior Materials:
The leather quality surpasses mainstream brands though falls short of higher-tier Audis.
The A3's compact dimensions result in limited practicality:
Cargo Capacity:
Families needing genuine utility should consider the Q3 crossover instead.
The 2017 model year brought exciting performance options including a new model.
The S3 uses an upgraded 2.0-liter producing 292 horsepower and 280 lb-ft of torque[20]. Enhancements include:
S3 Features:
Used S3 prices range from $18,000-28,000, offering genuine performance at reasonable prices.
The 2017 marked the debut of the RS3 sedan in the United States[20].
The legendary 2.5-liter five-cylinder produces 394 horsepower and 354 lb-ft of torque. Performance includes:
RS3 Performance:
The RS3 commands $35,000-45,000 used, competing with newer BMW M2 performance models.
The plug-in hybrid variant offers alternative efficiency[21]:
e-tron Specifications:
The added complexity and unknown battery longevity make e-tron models risky for used buyers.
Evaluating alternatives helps determine if the A3 best meets specific needs.
The CLA 250 offers more dramatic styling with 208 horsepower. Mercedes advantages include:
CLA Strengths:
However, the A3's superior build quality, better rear visibility, and more refined ride make it the better daily driver.
The 230i coupe delivers 248 horsepower with rear-wheel drive dynamics. BMW advantages include:
2 Series Benefits:
The A3 counters with four-door practicality, standard all-wheel drive availability, and the debut of Virtual Cockpit technology.
The ILX provides mainstream reliability at lower prices. Acura benefits include:
ILX Advantages:
The A3's genuine luxury materials, turbocharged performance, and available Quattro all-wheel drive justify its premium for brand-conscious buyers.
Evaluating the 2017 A3 requires balancing improved reliability against persistent issues.
The facelift brought substantial improvements that make 2017 models preferable:
2017 Advantages:
These improvements justify the typical $2,000-3,000 premium over pre-facelift models.
Given known issues, professional inspection proves essential. According to Autvex experts, focus areas include:
Inspection Priorities:
Budget $200-300 for comprehensive inspection that could prevent thousands in unexpected repairs.
Current pricing makes the 2017 A3 attractive for specific buyers:
Value Proposition:
However, the nearly guaranteed water pump replacement ($1,500-2,000) must factor into purchase decisions.
Begin your search by determining whether the base 186-horsepower engine suffices or if the 220-horsepower Quattro's substantial performance advantage justifies its $2,000 premium—test drive both as the difference proves dramatic. Use NHTSA's website to verify all recalls have been completed, particularly the fuel leak and airbag issues that affect safety. Schedule pre-purchase inspections at specialists familiar with 8V A3s, specifically checking for coolant residue around the water pump and thermostat housing.
Request complete maintenance records with particular attention to DSG services at 40,000-mile intervals, as skipped services virtually guarantee expensive failures. Budget for the inevitable water pump replacement if not already completed—set aside $1,500-2,000 for this nearly universal repair. Research independent German car specialists in your area who typically charge 40-50% less than dealers while maintaining expertise.
Consider whether Virtual Cockpit proves essential—equipped models command premiums but transform the interior experience. Compare insurance quotes as the A3's luxury classification can increase premiums 15-25% versus mainstream sedans. Strongly favor Quattro models despite the premium, as the performance improvement and all-wheel drive capability significantly enhance daily usability.
According to Autvex market analysis, well-maintained 2017 Quattro models with Virtual Cockpit, complete service history, and documented water pump replacement represent the sweet spot for value in the luxury compact segment.
Please share by clicking this button!
Visit our site and see all other available articles!