The 2019 Audi A3 represents a "sweet spot" year of the mature 8V generation (2015-2020) with most early production issues resolved, offering buyers a significant choice between the 184-horsepower front-wheel drive 40 TFSI and the considerably more powerful 228-horsepower Quattro 45 TFSI, with current used prices ranging from $12,370 to $28,495 depending on mileage and specification. While this late-generation model delivers proven technology and refined driving dynamics at attractive used prices, buyers must carefully verify completion of critical airbag recalls affecting 153,152 vehicles and ensure the DSG transmission's mandatory 40,000-mile service has been performed to avoid costly failures.
The 2019 model year occupies a unique position in the A3's lifecycle, benefiting from years of refinement while avoiding the uncertainties of newer generations.
The 2019 A3 sits strategically as the penultimate year of the third-generation 8V platform, which ran from 2015 through 2020[1]. This timing proves significant for used car buyers—by 2019, Audi had addressed most early-generation teething issues that plagued 2015-2016 models, including water pump failures and transmission software bugs. According to Autvex's analysis of warranty data, the 2019 model shows approximately 30% fewer reported issues than the first two years of the generation. The mature platform means parts availability remains strong, technicians are thoroughly familiar with service procedures, and most software glitches have been resolved through updates.
The 2019 model received subtle but meaningful mid-cycle refresh updates that modernized its appearance without dramatic changes[2]. Visual enhancements included:
2019 Facelift Changes:
These updates kept the A3 competitive against newer rivals while maintaining the proven mechanicals underneath. The facelift successfully bridged the gap between the original 2015 design and the completely new 2022 generation.
The S line package transforms the A3's appearance and dynamics, making it a popular choice in the used market. S line models feature sport-tuned suspension lowered by 15mm, unique front and rear bumpers, side skirts, and larger wheels[3]. Crucially, many S line models came equipped with the more powerful 45 TFSI engine and Quattro all-wheel drive, though some front-wheel drive S line models exist. Interior upgrades include sport seats with enhanced bolstering, a flat-bottom steering wheel, and aluminum pedals. These variants command approximately $2,000-3,000 premiums in the used car market due to their enhanced appearance and performance.
Current market values reflect significant depreciation from original MSRP, creating opportunities for value-conscious luxury buyers.
According to Edmunds data, typical dealer retail prices for a 2019 Audi A3 range from $21,175 for average-condition models to $22,008 for outstanding examples[4]. These prices assume:
Pricing Assumptions:
The relatively narrow price range suggests consistent market valuation, though specific configurations can fall outside these averages. Private party sales typically run 8-12% lower than dealer prices, though require more buyer diligence.
The drivetrain choice significantly impacts both pricing and desirability. TrueCar data shows 2019 A3s currently listed from $12,370 to $28,495, with the wide range primarily reflecting drivetrain differences[5]:
| Configuration | Typical Price Range | Average Mileage |
|---|---|---|
| 40 TFSI FWD | $12,370-$18,900 | 65,000-85,000 |
| 45 TFSI Quattro | $17,888-$28,495 | 45,000-70,000 |
| S3 Performance | $25,000-$35,000 | 35,000-55,000 |
The Quattro models command substantial premiums not just for all-wheel drive capability but also the more powerful engine that typically accompanies it.
The 2019 A3's original pricing started around $33,000 for base Premium FWD models and exceeded $42,000 for loaded Prestige Quattro variants[6]. Current depreciation analysis shows:
Depreciation Breakdown:
This depreciation curve suggests the steepest value loss has already occurred, making current purchases relatively stable investments for the next 2-3 years.
The 2019 A3 follows typical luxury compact sedan depreciation patterns, losing approximately 50-55% of its value over six years[7]. Factors affecting depreciation include:
Value Retention Factors:
Autvex market analysis indicates S line Quattro models with under 40,000 miles represent the best value retention, depreciating approximately 8-10% annually versus 12-15% for base FWD models.
The dramatic performance difference between engine options represents the most critical decision for 2019 A3 buyers.
The base powertrain delivers adequate but uninspiring performance that may disappoint drivers expecting German driving dynamics.
The detuned EA888 Gen 3B engine prioritizes efficiency over performance, using a smaller turbocharger and conservative tuning[8]. Key specifications include:
40 TFSI Engine Details:
The broad torque curve provides reasonable responsiveness in daily driving, though the modest output struggles when fully loaded or during aggressive acceleration. The engine feels particularly strained above 4,500 rpm where power delivery plateaus noticeably.
The efficiency-focused tuning delivers EPA ratings of 27 city/36 highway mpg, with real-world averages around 30-31 mpg[8]. Premium fuel remains recommended for optimal performance, though many owners report acceptable operation on regular with slightly reduced power. The 13.2-gallon tank provides approximately 400-mile range in mixed driving. This efficiency makes the FWD model attractive for commuters prioritizing fuel costs over performance.
The upgraded powertrain transforms the A3 from competent to genuinely engaging, justifying its premium pricing.
The same basic engine receives significant upgrades including a larger turbocharger, upgraded intercooler, and performance calibration[9]. The result is:
45 TFSI Performance Gains:
This configuration matches competitors like the BMW 228i Gran Coupe while delivering the added traction benefits of all-wheel drive.
The performance and all-wheel drive exact an efficiency penalty, with ratings dropping to 22 city/30 highway mpg[9]. Real-world observations show:
Quattro Fuel Consumption:
Most Quattro buyers accept these trade-offs for the substantial performance and capability improvements.
The dual-clutch transmission delivers quick shifts but requires understanding of its characteristics and maintenance needs. The S tronic uses two separate clutches for odd and even gears, enabling shifts in under 200 milliseconds[10]. However, common behaviors include:
DSG Characteristics:
These traits are inherent to dual-clutch design rather than defects, though some drivers find them unacceptable compared to traditional automatics.
Acceleration figures highlight the substantial performance gap between variants:
| Model | 0-60 mph | Quarter Mile | Top Speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 TFSI FWD | 7.8 seconds | 15.9 seconds | 130 mph |
| 45 TFSI Quattro | 6.0 seconds | 14.5 seconds | 130 mph (limited) |
| S3 (reference) | 4.7 seconds | 13.2 seconds | 155 mph (limited) |
The nearly two-second difference to 60 mph makes the 45 TFSI feel like an entirely different car, particularly in real-world passing situations.
The 2019 A3's reliability story proves complex, with resolved early-generation issues offset by some persistent problems.
Consumer Reports rates the 2019 A3 as above average in reliability, though with specific areas of concern[11]. What Car?'s reliability survey gave the 8V generation A3 a score of 88.5%, ranking 15th out of 29 family cars[12]. Key findings include:
Reliability Patterns:
RepairPal provides a more pessimistic assessment, rating the A3 at 2.5 out of 5 stars, ranking 25th out of 26 luxury compact cars[11].
A critical safety recall affects 153,152 A3-generation vehicles including all 2019 models, involving the Passenger Occupant Detection System (PODS)[13]. The issue involves:
PODS Recall Details:
The challenge is parts availability—many owners report waiting over a year for the fix. Verify recall completion through NHTSA's website before purchase, as this safety issue significantly impacts passenger protection.
The MMI system represents the A3's most problematic area, with various malfunctions reported by owners.
The retractable 7-inch display suffers from mechanical and electronic failures[12]:
Screen Problems:
Replacement costs range from $800-1,500 when out of warranty, making this a significant consideration for used buyers.
Bluetooth and smartphone integration prove unreliable for many owners, with problems including:
Connectivity Issues:
Software updates partially address these issues, though some vehicles continue experiencing problems despite updates.
The dual-clutch transmission requires fluid and filter changes every 40,000 miles without exception[14]. This service is critical because:
DSG Service Importance:
Service costs approximately $400-600 at dealers or $300-400 at independent shops. Always verify service history before purchase.
While generally reliable, the 2.0 TFSI engine has some known weak points requiring attention.
The diverter valve's rubber diaphragm tears over time, causing performance loss and unusual sounds[15]:
Diverter Valve Symptoms:
Replacement costs $200-400, with upgraded aftermarket valves offering better durability than OEM parts.
Direct injection engines inherently suffer from carbon accumulation on intake valves since fuel doesn't wash over them[15]. By 60,000-80,000 miles, symptoms include:
Carbon Buildup Effects:
Carbon cleaning service costs $500-800 and restores performance. Some owners use catch cans or intake valve cleaners as preventive measures.
A recall affects 2017-2020 A3 models for start-stop system malfunctions that could cause power steering loss or delayed braking[16]. Symptoms include:
Start-Stop Issues:
Dealers repair this issue free under recall, though parts availability varies. Always verify completion before purchase.
Additional concerns include front suspension creaking even at low mileage, typically from strut mounts or control arm bushings. Water pump failures, while less common than early 8V models, still occur around 60,000-80,000 miles at repair costs of $700-1,000. Regular maintenance and prompt attention to unusual noises help prevent major failures.
The 2019 A3's cabin balances quality materials with dated technology compared to current standards.
The retractable display represents both a unique feature and potential liability. The motorized 7-inch screen deploys from the dashboard on startup, creating a clean appearance when retracted[17]. However, the mechanism adds complexity:
Pop-Up Screen Characteristics:
While distinctive, many find the pop-up screen gimmicky compared to modern integrated displays.
Available on higher trims, the Virtual Cockpit transforms the driver experience with its high-resolution digital display[17]. Features include:
Virtual Cockpit Benefits:
This $500-750 option when new proves worthwhile for technology-focused buyers, significantly modernizing the interior experience.
Even base models include impressive equipment justifying the premium positioning.
Smartphone integration comes standard across all trims, though implementation requires wired connection[18]. The system works reliably when connected, offering:
Connectivity Features:
Many owners primarily use CarPlay/Android Auto rather than the native MMI system, making this feature particularly valuable.
Standard leather upholstery provides appropriate luxury for the segment, with multiple color options including black, beige, and rock gray. The leather quality surpasses mainstream brands though falls short of higher-tier Audis. Three-stage seat heating warms quickly, reaching maximum temperature in under two minutes. The heating elements prove reliable, with few reported failures even at higher mileage.
The expansive glass roof comes standard on all trims, unusual for this class[18]. The front section tilts and slides electronically, featuring:
Sunroof Features:
Some owners report drain clogs causing water intrusion, requiring periodic cleaning to prevent interior damage.
The A3's compact dimensions result in limited practicality with just 10.6 cubic feet of trunk space[19]. This compares unfavorably to competitors:
| Model | Cargo Capacity |
|---|---|
| 2019 Audi A3 | 10.6 cu ft |
| 2019 BMW 2 Series | 12.0 cu ft |
| 2019 Mercedes CLA | 11.9 cu ft |
| 2019 Acura ILX | 12.3 cu ft |
The small trunk and tight rear seats limit the A3's family car credentials, making it best suited for couples or small families.
Understanding the S3 and RS3 helps contextualize the standard A3's position in the performance hierarchy.
The S3 bridges the gap between regular A3 and full RS performance, using an upgraded 2.0-liter producing 288 horsepower and 280 lb-ft of torque[20]. Enhancements include:
S3 Performance Features:
Used S3 prices range from $25,000-35,000, offering genuine performance at reasonable prices compared to new models.
The RS3 stands apart with its unique 2.5-liter five-cylinder engine, one of the last of its kind[20].
The turbocharged five-cylinder produces 394 horsepower and 354 lb-ft of torque, with its 1-2-4-5-3 firing order creating an unmistakable exhaust note. Performance statistics include:
RS3 Performance:
This represents supercar-level performance in a compact sedan, though used prices of $40,000-50,000 reflect its capabilities.
Evaluating alternatives helps determine if the A3 best meets specific needs and preferences.
The CLA 250 offers more dramatic styling with its coupe profile and 221 horsepower, exceeding the A3 40 TFSI's output[21]. Mercedes advantages include:
CLA Strengths:
However, the A3 counters with superior interior quality, more rear headroom, and the availability of the much more powerful 45 TFSI engine. The Audi's understated styling ages better than the CLA's polarizing design.
The 2 Series sedan wasn't available until 2020, but the 2 Series coupe offers an interesting comparison. BMW advantages include:
2 Series Benefits:
The A3 offers more practical four-door configuration and available all-wheel drive, making it the better daily driver for most buyers.
The ILX provides mainstream reliability at lower prices but can't match the A3's premium feel[22]. Acura advantages include:
ILX Strengths:
The A3's genuine luxury materials, available all-wheel drive, and superior technology justify its premium for buyers prioritizing refinement over reliability.
Understanding generational differences helps buyers decide between model years.
The 2020 model year brought minimal changes, making 2019 models nearly identical for less money. The only notable updates included:
2020 Changes:
Smart buyers can save $1,000-2,000 choosing 2019 over 2020 with virtually no compromise.
The 2022 redesign introduced fundamental improvements that make newer models feel generations ahead[23]:
2022+ Advantages:
The technology gap alone may justify the $5,000-8,000 premium for newer models, particularly for tech-focused buyers.
The 2019's conservative styling has aged well compared to some competitors, though it looks dated next to the angular 2022+ design. Considerations include:
Styling Comparison:
Some buyers prefer the subtle 2019 styling, while others want the latest design language.
Evaluating the 2019 A3 requires honest assessment of priorities and risk tolerance.
The 2019 A3 suits specific buyer profiles particularly well:
Ideal Buyers:
Conversely, reliability-focused buyers or those needing genuine family space should consider alternatives.
Given known issues, professional inspection proves essential before purchase. Key areas include:
Inspection Priorities:
Budget $200-300 for comprehensive inspection that could prevent thousands in unexpected repairs.
Complete service records significantly impact both reliability and value. According to Autvex analysis, vehicles with full dealer history experience 25% fewer major issues and command 10-15% price premiums. Critical records include:
Essential Documentation:
Missing service history should trigger either walking away or significant price negotiations.
Begin your search by determining whether the base 184-horsepower engine suffices or if the 228-horsepower Quattro's substantial performance advantage justifies its premium—test drive both as the difference is dramatic. Use NHTSA's website to verify all recalls have been completed, particularly the critical PODS airbag issue that affects passenger safety. Schedule pre-purchase inspections at Audi specialists who understand DSG transmission evaluation and can scan for stored fault codes.
Request complete maintenance records with particular attention to DSG services at 40,000-mile intervals, as skipped services virtually guarantee expensive failures. Budget for higher ownership costs, including premium fuel, synthetic oil changes, and potential repairs averaging $800-1,200 annually. Compare insurance quotes as the A3's luxury classification can increase premiums 15-25% versus mainstream sedans.
Consider whether the dated pop-up MMI screen bothers you—spend time with it during test drives as some find it charming while others consider it unacceptable. Evaluate if spending $5,000-8,000 more for a 2022+ model with modern technology makes sense for your situation. Research independent German car specialists in your area who typically charge 30-40% less than dealers while maintaining expertise.
Finally, strongly favor 45 TFSI Quattro S line models despite their premium, as the performance improvement transforms the driving experience and these models retain value approximately 20% better than base variants. According to Autvex market analysis, well-maintained 2019 Quattro models with under 50,000 miles and complete service histories represent the sweet spot for reliability, performance, and value retention in the used luxury compact segment.
Please share by clicking this button!
Visit our site and see all other available articles!