When shopping for a used Audi A5, avoid the 2010-2014 and 2018-2019 model years due to significant reliability problems and costly repairs. The 2011 A5 stands out as the most problematic year, with excessive oil consumption requiring up to one quart every 1,000 miles, timing chain tensioner failures, and broken pistons leading to complete engine replacement[1]. Understanding which A5 years to steer clear of can save American buyers from facing repair costs exceeding $15,000 for major engine work while ensuring a more reliable luxury coupe ownership experience.
Technical Service Bulletin patterns reveal systematic problems across specific A5 generations, with problematic years showing distinct failure trends in critical systems. The first-generation A5s (2008-2016) experienced more widespread reliability issues compared to the second generation, though certain second-generation years still present concerns[2].
First-generation vs second-generation differences show varying problem areas:
Consumer complaint categories consistently highlight engine problems (55%), electrical issues (25%), and transmission failures (15%) as the most reported concerns across problematic model years[3]. The 2.0 TFSI engines prior to 2012 have an inherent design fault leading to excessive oil consumption, affecting A5, A4, and Q5 models with engine codes CAEB, CDNC, and CNDC[4].
Consumer Reports reliability ratings provide clear indicators of problematic A5 years through comprehensive owner surveys and expert analysis. The organization expects the 2025 A5 to be more reliable than the average new car based on data from previous generations and Audi's brand score[5].
NHTSA complaint database analysis reveals specific patterns for problematic years:
The NHTSA database shows the 2011 A5 with extensive complaints about excessive engine oil consumption, with owners reporting consumption rates of 1.08 quarts per 1,000 miles[1]. CarComplaints.com data confirms systematic issues across multiple model years, particularly highlighting the 2010-2014 period as especially problematic.
Average repair costs for the worst A5 years significantly exceed reliable alternatives, with engine-related repairs representing the most expensive category. Oil consumption repairs typically range from $3,000-$8,000, while complete engine replacement can cost $15,000-$20,000[6].
Engine replacement and major component failure expenses include:
Long-term ownership cost comparisons show problematic A5 years costing significantly more than reliable alternatives. Automotive analysis from Autvex indicates that avoiding problematic years can save owners $8,000-$15,000 over a five-year ownership period compared to problematic model years[7].
Insurance implications also affect problematic years, with some insurers charging higher premiums for models with known reliability issues or extensive recall histories.
The 2010-2012 A5 model years were severely affected by the Takata airbag recall, which caused airbag deployment failures and metal fragment injuries to occupants. The defective inflators can explode when deployed, sending sharp shrapnel flying at drivers and passengers[8].
Major safety concerns included:
Multiple electrical system problems plagued these years:
The Volkswagen and Audi $42 million settlement in 2021 provided compensation for owners affected by the recall delays and associated costs[9]. Extended recall repair timelines meant some owners waited over two years for parts availability, with many driving potentially dangerous vehicles during this period.
The 2011 A5 earned the distinction as the single worst model year due to multiple catastrophic problems affecting engine reliability and safety systems. Excessive oil consumption became the most widespread issue, with engines burning up to one quart every 1,000 miles due to defective piston rings[1].
Critical engine problems included:
Drivetrain problems affected daily usability:
One Puerto Rico owner documented their vehicle consuming 1.08 quarts in 1,000 miles despite following all recommended maintenance procedures. Audi of America acknowledged that 126,000 vehicles presented excessive oil consumption but attempted to avoid warranty coverage through technicalities[1].
The 2013-2014 model years represented the peak of A5 engine reliability problems, with complete engine failures occurring under 100,000 miles in numerous cases. These years experienced the highest rate of catastrophic engine problems requiring complete replacement[10].
Major engine component failures:
Zero cylinder compression issues required complete engine rebuilds:
Many owners reported engine failures under warranty being denied due to alleged maintenance issues, despite following all recommended service intervals. The complexity of proving maintenance compliance created significant disputes between owners and Audi dealerships.
Despite being part of the redesigned second generation, the 2018-2019 A5 continued experiencing reliability problems that carried over from development issues. These years proved that newer doesn't always mean more reliable[11].
Rapid tire wear became a signature problem:
Electronic system malfunctions affected daily operation:
Oil leaks and faulty thermostats continued despite TSB releases:
The 2009 A5 represented the inaugural model year, suffering from typical first-year production problems that affect most new vehicle launches. While not as severely problematic as later years, it still requires careful evaluation[12].
First-year production problems included:
Limited recall history compared to later years, but early reliability concerns included electrical system inconsistencies and minor engine management issues. Parts availability challenges for the inaugural model year created longer repair times and higher costs for specialized components.
The 2012 model year extended the Takata airbag recall issues beyond the initial 2010-2011 years, with 6 total complaints and 29 reported problems documented by consumer reporting agencies[13].
Extended airbag recall issues included:
Ongoing electrical system malfunctions carried over from earlier years:
Despite being part of the mature second generation, the 2020 A5 experienced 4 reported problems and 4 recalls for various system failures, indicating inconsistent quality control[14].
System failures included:
Inconsistent owner experiences ranged from completely trouble-free ownership to multiple warranty claims, suggesting quality control variations during production. Warranty claims often required multiple dealer visits to properly diagnose and resolve issues.
The 2015 A5 achieved remarkable owner satisfaction with 84% of owners rating it 5 out of 5 stars, making it the most successful first-generation model year[15]. With only 1 complaint and 8 problems reported across all consumer databases, it represents excellent value in the used market.
Outstanding reliability metrics:
3 recalls were issued but overall owner satisfaction remained exceptionally high, with most recalls addressing minor issues that didn't affect daily reliability. The 2015 model year benefits from years of refinement and problem resolution from earlier first-generation issues.
The 2017 A5 marked the successful launch of the second generation with 0 complaints and only 3 problems reported, demonstrating significant improvement over problematic years[16]. 2 recalls were issued but overall reliability showed dramatic improvement.
Second-generation improvements:
The 2017 launch year proved that Audi successfully addressed the systematic issues plaguing earlier generations, making it an excellent entry point for second-generation A5 ownership.
Recent model years demonstrate continued reliability improvements with minimal complaints and recalls:
Current generation benefits:
Consumer Reports expects continued reliability improvements for 2024 and 2025 model years based on platform maturity and Audi's brand improvements[5].
Oil consumption patterns remain the most persistent A5 problem, particularly affecting 2.0 TFSI engines from 2008-2012 with inherent design flaws in piston rings and PCV systems[4]. Normal consumption should not exceed one quart per 5,000 miles.
Timing chain tensioner failure symptoms:
Water pump leaks and cooling system problems:
Fuel injector malfunctions cause engine stalling, misfiring, and reduced fuel economy. Replacement typically costs $400-$600 per injector, with multiple injectors often requiring simultaneous replacement.
MMI infotainment system issues consistently appear across A5 generations:
Warning lights and intermittent electrical faults:
Advanced safety system malfunctions in newer A5s include backup camera glitches, electronic trunk failures causing injuries, and connectivity issues with modern smartphones requiring frequent software updates.
Multitronic CVT transmission problems affect 2007-2016 A5 models with continuous variable transmissions, causing power loss, shuddering, and overheating during demanding driving conditions[17].
S tronic automatic transmission malfunctions:
Drivetrain noise and wheel rubbing problems:
Power loss issues manifest as reduced acceleration, especially when climbing hills or merging onto highways. Many owners report transmission malfunction warnings that require immediate dealer attention.
Oil consumption testing requires extended evaluation periods to identify problematic engines. Request documentation of oil consumption over the previous 5,000 miles, and be suspicious of any A5 requiring frequent oil additions between service intervals.
Timing chain tensioner evaluation:
Cooling system inspection:
Engine compression testing can reveal internal damage from oil consumption or timing chain issues. All cylinders should show consistent compression readings within manufacturer specifications.
Complete infotainment system testing should verify all multimedia functions, navigation accuracy, and smartphone connectivity. Test Apple CarPlay and Android Auto functionality thoroughly.
Diagnostic scanning using professional equipment can reveal stored error codes indicating ongoing problems. Many intermittent issues store codes even when warning lights aren't currently active.
Airbag system operation requires verification of proper functionality and Takata airbag recall completion. Request certificates proving recall work completion, especially for 2010-2012 model years.
Electronic trunk and safety feature testing should include backup camera operation, parking sensors, and any electronic trunk mechanisms that have caused injuries in problematic years.
Complete maintenance record verification must demonstrate regular oil changes, timing chain service, and cooling system maintenance. Look for patterns of repeated repairs indicating ongoing problems.
Takata airbag recall completion certificates are essential for 2010-2012 model years. Unresolved recalls indicate potential safety hazards and legal liability issues.
TSB work completion documentation should show resolution of known Technical Service Bulletins, particularly those addressing oil consumption, timing chain issues, and electrical problems.
Extended warranty options deserve serious consideration for any A5 outside original factory warranty. Audi service requirements can be expensive, making extended coverage valuable for complex luxury vehicles.
BMW 4 Series reliability comparison shows mixed results compared to A5, with both German luxury brands requiring higher maintenance costs than Japanese alternatives. The 4 Series has a 5.8/10 reliability rating compared to varying A5 ratings by year[18].
| Comparison Factor | Audi A5 | BMW 4 Series | Lexus RC |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reliability Rating | 6.5/10 (varies by year) | 5.8/10 | 7.5/10 |
| Average Life Expectancy | 10.0 years | 10.2 years | 12.8 years |
| 200k Mile Probability | 2.3% | 2.2% | 18.5% |
Mercedes C-Class Coupe dependability typically matches A5 reliability but with higher maintenance costs. Lexus RC reliability advantages include significantly longer life expectancy and much higher probability of reaching 200,000 miles[19].
Infiniti Q60 reliability metrics show improved dependability over recent years with the naturally aspirated V6 engine proving more reliable than turbocharged German alternatives. Warranty coverage includes 4-year/60,000-mile comprehensive coverage.
Cadillac ATS Coupe dependability varies significantly by model year, with some years showing excellent reliability while others experience significant problems. Service costs typically run lower than German competitors due to domestic parts availability.
Genesis G70 reliability record benefits from Hyundai's quality improvements and industry-leading warranty coverage including 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain protection. Initial quality ratings consistently exceed both Audi and BMW.
Honda Accord Coupe (discontinued but available used) offers proven long-term dependability with significantly lower maintenance costs than any luxury alternative. Average life expectancy exceeds 13 years with proper maintenance.
Toyota Camry reliability record includes consistently high ratings and lower ownership costs than any luxury competitor. Total cost of ownership typically runs $8,000-$12,000 less over five years compared to problematic A5 years.
Mazda6 features offer luxury-level interior amenities at mainstream pricing with above-average reliability ratings. Maintenance costs remain significantly lower than German luxury alternatives while providing similar driving experience.
For buyers considering alternatives, researching how many miles Audis can last compared to Japanese competitors reveals significant long-term cost differences favoring non-luxury brands.
Please share by clicking this button!
Visit our site and see all other available articles!