2024 BMW X1 Review: Redesign Worth the Price?

The 2024 BMW X1 builds on its complete 2023 third-generation redesign introducing the high-performance M35i xDrive variant delivering 312 horsepower and 5.4-second 0-60 mph acceleration—making it “probably the most fun SUV under $50,000” per automotive reviewers^[1][2]. Starting at $38,600 for base xDrive28i and $49,900 for M35i, this completely redesigned compact luxury SUV earns IIHS Top Safety Pick+ (highest safety award) while delivering “chic, tech-forward cabin” with BMW’s latest iDrive 9 operating system^[2][3]. Car and Driver awards “Editors’ Choice” designation praising the X1’s confident handling and composed driving dynamics, though reviewers note M Sport suspension creates “stiff and bouncy” ride compromising daily comfort^[1][2]. MotorTrend declares redesigned X1 “best-looking” BMW vehicle representing “huge step up from outgoing generation in terms of styling, interior refinement, and tech”^[2].

What’s New for the 2024 BMW X1

Third-Generation Redesign (2023) Carries Forward

The 2024 X1 builds on complete 2023 third-generation redesign (U11 chassis) with minor updates for current model year. BMW introduces new M35i xDrive performance variant as range-topping model delivering 71 horsepower boost over base xDrive28i^[1][2]. Updated BMW iDrive system with QuickSelect functionality replaces previous generation’s OS 8.

BMW Operating System 9 debuts on M35i featuring redesigned home screen for easier navigation. No major exterior or interior changes differentiate 2024 from 2023 launch year—focus centers on powertrain expansion and infotainment refinement^[2]. Third-generation platform represents clean-sheet design addressing previous generation criticisms regarding conservative styling and dated technology.

2024 Model Year Updates:

• Third-generation carryover: Building on 2023 redesign
• New M35i variant: 312 HP performance model added
• iDrive system update: QuickSelect functionality
• BMW OS 9: Enhanced infotainment system
• No exterior changes: Design continues from 2023
• No interior updates: Cabin carries forward
• M35i exclusive features: M Sport components standard

New M35i xDrive Performance Model

The new-for-2024 M35i xDrive delivers 312 horsepower from enhanced BMW M TwinPower Turbo 2.0-liter inline-four engine maintaining 295 lb-ft torque of base model^[1][4]. This represents 71 HP advantage over xDrive28i’s 241 HP output creating most powerful X1 ever offered. BMW estimates 5.2-second 0-60 mph though real-world testing confirms quicker 5.4-second performance^[1].

M Sport suspension and M Sport brakes with upgraded calipers come standard enhancing handling dynamics and stopping power. MotorTrend testing achieved impressive 4.8-second 0-60 mph—significantly quicker than BMW’s conservative estimate^[2]. Standard 19-inch M wheels, sport seats with enhanced bolstering, and M-specific exhaust system distinguish M35i visually and acoustically from base trim. For buyers interested in BMW’s performance lineup, understanding how long it takes to buy a car helps set realistic purchasing expectations.

Pricing & Market Positioning

Base xDrive28i pricing starts around $38,600-$39,000 MSRP plus approximately $1,000-1,175 destination charge^[1][3]. Performance M35i commands $49,900 MSRP plus destination—approximately $11,000 premium over base model reflecting enhanced performance and standard equipment^[4]. First-year pricing for redesigned model positions X1 competitively versus Volvo XC40 and Mercedes-Benz GLB rivals.

Premium positioning versus previous generation reflects enhanced technology, improved interior quality, and expanded powertrain options. Entry-level BMW SUV positioning makes X1 accessible gateway into brand ownership at manageable pricing versus larger X3 starting significantly higher. According to Autvex automotive analysis, the redesigned X1 delivers best value proposition in compact luxury SUV segment balancing performance, features, and pricing.

2024 BMW X1 Design & Styling

All-New Third-Generation Exterior

Complete redesign for third generation (2023 launch) addresses previous generation’s conservative styling criticisms. MotorTrend declares redesigned X1 “best-looking” BMW vehicle showcasing bold evolution of brand’s design language^[2]. Large kidney grille with sharp edges dominates front fascia creating unmistakable BMW identity. Sharp LED headlights frame grille providing modern lighting signature.

Sculpted body lines and athletic stance emphasize dynamic character distinguishing X1 from bland competitors. Tall SUV proportions with aerodynamic contours balance utility with efficiency. Muscular wheelarches emphasize presence creating more confident appearance. “Huge step up from outgoing generation” per reviewer consensus praising transformation^[2].

Exterior Design Highlights:

• Large kidney grille: Bold BMW identity
• Sharp LED headlights: Modern signature lighting
• Sculpted body lines: Athletic character
• Tall SUV proportions: Commanding presence
• Aerodynamic contours: Efficiency optimization
• Muscular wheelarches: Confident stance
• Best-looking BMW: MotorTrend assessment

Build Quality & Dimensions

Subcompact luxury SUV classification with compact dimensions enabling urban maneuverability. Premium appearance exceeds expectations for entry-level positioning with quality materials and precise assembly. Five-door configuration with five-passenger seating accommodates typical family needs^[1].

Standard 18-inch wheels on xDrive28i provide efficient rolling stock while 19-inch wheels on M35i enhance visual presence and handling capability. Improved build quality over previous generation addresses historical BMW criticism regarding durability. Zero creaks, rattles, or panel gaps reported by reviewers praising assembly precision^[2].

Design Strengths & Weaknesses

Bold, confident styling versus conservative predecessor proves more visually striking than Mercedes-Benz GLB rivals. Angular, dynamic lines create athletic profile emphasizing BMW’s sporty heritage. Addresses previous generation styling criticisms transforming X1 into aspirational vehicle rather than anonymous appliance^[2].

However, oversized kidney grille may divide opinion among buyers preferring more restrained proportions. Modern BMW design language execution balances SUV practicality with sporty aesthetics successfully though traditionalists may prefer smaller grille. Overall design successfully differentiates X1 in crowded compact luxury SUV segment.

2024 BMW X1 Trim Levels & Pricing

xDrive28i: Base Model Overview

Starting MSRP around $38,600-$39,000 plus destination delivers comprehensive equipment justifying premium positioning. 241 horsepower turbocharged 2.0-liter inline-four engine produces 295 lb-ft torque from just 1,500 rpm enabling confident acceleration^[1][3]. BMW estimates 6.2-second 0-60 mph though real-world testing confirms 5.6-second performance—quicker than conservative claim^[2].

Seven-speed dual-clutch automatic transmission provides lightning-fast shifts though some reviewers note “unrefined at low speeds” behavior^[2]. xDrive all-wheel drive standard ensures confident traction year-round conditions. EPA estimates 28 MPG combined delivering competitive efficiency for turbocharged AWD luxury SUV^[3].

xDrive28i Standard Equipment:

• 241 HP turbocharged 2.0L engine
• 295 lb-ft torque from 1,500 rpm
• 5.6-second 0-60 mph (tested)
• 7-speed dual-clutch automatic
• xDrive AWD standard
• 28 MPG combined EPA rating
• 18-inch wheels standard
• LED headlights standard
• Dual-zone climate control

M35i xDrive: Performance Model (New 2024)

Starting MSRP $49,900 plus destination commands $11,000 premium over base model delivering substantial performance enhancement. 312 horsepower M TwinPower Turbo engine with 295 lb-ft torque and enhanced delivery characteristics transforms driving character^[1][4]. BMW estimates 5.2-second 0-60 mph with Car and Driver confirming 5.4-second real-world performance—MotorTrend achieved blistering 4.8-second time^[1][2].

M Sport suspension standard sharpens handling dynamics though creates firmer ride. M Sport brakes with upgraded four-piston front calipers and larger rotors ensure superior stopping—Car and Driver testing confirmed five-foot shorter 70-mph stop versus base model^[1]. Sport seats with enhanced bolstering provide better lateral support. 19-inch M wheels standard with optional 20-inch upgrade available.

Specification	xDrive28i	M35i xDrive
Starting MSRP	$38,600-39,000	$49,900
Engine	2.0L Turbo I-4	2.0L M Turbo I-4
Horsepower	241 HP	312 HP
Torque	295 lb-ft	295 lb-ft
0-60 mph (BMW)	6.2 sec	5.2 sec
0-60 mph (tested)	5.6 sec	4.8-5.4 sec
EPA Combined	28 MPG	27 MPG (est.)
Wheels	18-inch	19-inch
Suspension	Standard	Adaptive M
Brakes	Standard	M Sport upgraded

Standard Equipment Across Lineup

Comprehensive standard equipment distinguishes BMW from budget competitors. BMW Curved Display integrates 10.25-inch digital instrument cluster with 10.7-inch central touchscreen in seamless frameless design^[2]. iDrive 9 operating system with QuickSelect functionality debuts on M35i providing enhanced responsiveness and redesigned home screen for easier navigation^[2].

Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto standard enable seamless smartphone integration though some owners report connectivity issues. Active Driving Assistant safety suite includes blind-spot monitoring, forward collision warning with automatic emergency braking, and lane departure warning as standard^[2][3]. LED headlights, dual-zone automatic climate control, and synthetic leather upholstery complete comprehensive baseline equipment.

Optional Packages & Upgrades

M Sport Design package available for xDrive28i adds adaptive suspension, grippier sport seats with better bolstering, and M Sport exterior styling elements. Premium audio system upgrades enhance sound quality. Enhanced driver assistance packages expand semi-autonomous capabilities^[2].

360-degree camera system simplifies parking in tight spaces. Technology packages available add enhanced navigation features, head-up display, and augmented reality navigation (M35i). Buyers should carefully evaluate actual needs versus marketing appeal—many optional features prove rarely used in daily driving.

Which Trim Level to Choose

Base xDrive28i recommended for most buyers delivering sufficient 241 HP power for daily driving needs. Better ride quality than firm M35i enhances everyday comfort. The $10,000+ price difference proves hard justifying for marginal performance advantage most drivers won’t exploit in typical commuting^[1][2].

M35i justified only for dedicated performance enthusiasts prioritizing ultimate handling sharpness and acceleration bragging rights. Reviewers note M35i “hardly necessary for most shoppers” given base model’s engaging character^[2]. Performance compromises daily comfort through firmer suspension creating “stiff and bouncy” ride on rough roads^[2][4]. Base model offers better value proposition balancing performance, comfort, and pricing.

2024 BMW X1 Performance & Driving Dynamics

Engine Options & Specifications

Both 2024 trims utilize turbocharged 2.0-liter inline-four engine architecture though different tuning levels. Base xDrive28i features BMW TwinPower Turbo producing 241 HP at 4,500 rpm with 295 lb-ft torque^[1][3]. Performance M35i upgrades to BMW M TwinPower Turbo generating 312 HP with enhanced performance tuning maintaining same torque figure^[1][4].

Both engines pair with seven-speed dual-clutch automatic transmission providing lightning-fast shifts in Sport mode though “unrefined at low speeds” per reviewer feedback^[2]. Standard xDrive all-wheel drive ensures confident traction both trims distributing power optimally between axles. Premium unleaded fuel recommended both variants optimizing performance and efficiency.

Engine Technical Specifications:

• xDrive28i: 2.0L TwinPower Turbo inline-four
• 241 HP at 4,500 rpm / 295 lb-ft torque
• M35i: 2.0L M TwinPower Turbo inline-four
• 312 HP / 295 lb-ft torque (enhanced)
• Both: 7-speed dual-clutch automatic
• Both: xDrive AWD standard
• Fuel: Premium unleaded recommended

Acceleration & Real-World Testing

Base xDrive28i delivers 6.2-second 0-60 mph per BMW estimate though MotorTrend testing confirmed 5.6-second real-world performance—substantially quicker than claimed^[2]. Performance M35i achieves BMW’s 5.2-second 0-60 mph estimate with Car and Driver confirming 5.4-second testing^[1]. MotorTrend achieved blistering 4.8-second 0-60 mph showcasing “highly caffeinated” performance^[2].

However, turbo lag noted on both models with 5.9-second 5-to-60 mph time indicating delay during rolling acceleration^[1]. Quick for compact SUV segment though not instantaneous like naturally-aspirated engines. Performance proves “zippy” and engaging for enthusiastic driving within segment context^[2].

Handling & Driving Experience

Universal reviewer consensus declares X1 “one of most enjoyable vehicles to drive in its class” praising confident and composed handling^[2][3]. Impressive grip and small size maneuverability enable easy city driving with nimble dimensions. Quick, responsive steering praised universally providing excellent feedback and precision control.

Athletic character distinguishes X1 from bland rivals prioritizing comfort over engagement. “Engaging drive” per universal consensus with “probably most fun SUV under $50,000” assessment for M35i variant^[1][2]. Confident handling inspires spirited driving approaching speeds exceeding typical compact SUV expectations. For buyers exploring BMW’s broader lineup, the BMW Z4 delivers pure roadster driving dynamics.

Ride Quality & Comfort Balance

Base xDrive28i delivers “comfortable and quiet ride” with refined ride quality for daily driving situations^[2][3]. However, M Sport package makes ride “stiff and bouncy” compromising everyday comfort^[2][4]. M35i adaptive suspension feels “harsh on rough roads” per multiple reviewers noting excessive firmness^[2][4].

Sporty suspension “great for corners, poor elsewhere” creating compromise unsuitable for typical buyers prioritizing daily comfort^[4]. Stiff suspension adds creakiness over bumps. Tire noise seeps in on highway detracting from luxury ambiance^[2]. Base model provides better all-around compromise balancing ride quality and handling dynamics for non-enthusiast buyers.

Transmission & Drivetrain Behavior

Seven-speed dual-clutch transmission delivers “great in Sport mode performance” with lightning-fast shifts^[2]. However, system proves “unrefined at low speeds” creating jerky behavior during parking maneuvers^[2]. Can be slow to downshift during aggressive throttle application requiring anticipation. Dual personalities emerge—sporty versus everyday driving creating compromise.

Engine start-stop system feels rough with abrupt operation frustrating owners^[5]. Some owners report transmission getting stuck in gears requiring service intervention. High rev in low gears during local driving reported by M35i owners suggesting calibration issues^[5]. For context on vehicle performance issues, understanding what happens when your car is totaled but still drivable provides valuable insurance knowledge.

2024 BMW X1 Fuel Economy & Efficiency

EPA Ratings by Trim

Base xDrive28i achieves EPA-estimated 25 city / 34 highway / 28 combined MPG delivering competitive efficiency for turbocharged AWD luxury SUV^[3]. Performance M35i returns slightly lower 21 city / 31 highway / 27 combined MPG (estimated) reflecting sportier tuning and enhanced power output^[1][4].

Decent fuel economy for turbocharged AWD SUV segment. Better efficiency than Mercedes-Benz GLB competitors. Competitive with Volvo XC40 ratings. Premium fuel recommended both trims optimizing performance though regular unleaded acceptable with reduced power output.

EPA Fuel Economy Ratings:

• xDrive28i city: 25 MPG
• xDrive28i highway: 34 MPG
• xDrive28i combined: 28 MPG
• M35i city: 21 MPG (est.)
• M35i highway: 31 MPG (est.)
• M35i combined: 27 MPG (est.)
• Fuel type: Premium unleaded recommended

Real-World Fuel Economy

Real-world highway driving generally matches EPA estimates under favorable conditions. However, Car and Driver testing revealed M35i returned 21 MPG versus 26 MPG combined EPA estimate—5 MPG shortfall indicating aggressive driving penalties^[1]. Base xDrive28i averaged 23 MPG versus 28 MPG EPA combined in similar testing^[1].

City driving with frequent acceleration reduces efficiency significantly with turbo engine requiring throttle enrichment. Cost to drive approximately $218/month estimated reflecting premium fuel pricing and typical driving patterns^[3]. Approximate 14.3-gallon fuel tank capacity provides 400-mile range (xDrive28i) and 370-mile range (M35i) between refueling stops.

Operating Cost Considerations

Premium fuel requirement increases operating costs approximately $0.30-0.50 per gallon versus regular unleaded—meaningful expense over ownership period. Better efficiency than larger BMW X3 justifies X1 selection for buyers prioritizing economy. Competitive fuel economy for luxury segment though mass-market competitors offer superior efficiency^[1].

Performance M35i sacrifices some efficiency for enhanced power output though remains reasonable for 312 HP performance. Overall operating costs manageable for buyers accepting premium fuel as luxury vehicle ownership expense.

2024 BMW X1 Interior & Comfort

Cabin Design & Modern Layout

Reviewers praise “chic, tech-forward cabin” representing “huge step up from outgoing generation” addressing historical weakness^[2][3]. Modern aesthetic with high-quality materials throughout. Excellent build quality praised universally with zero creaks, rattles, or panel gaps reported^[2].

Clean, techy design execution appeals to technology-focused buyers. Floating center console creates open feel maximizing perceived spaciousness. “Up there with better family SUV interiors” per reviewer assessment^[2]. Premium feel throughout cabin justifies luxury positioning distinguishing X1 from mass-market competitors.

Interior Design Highlights:

• Chic, tech-forward: Modern aesthetic
• Huge step up: Improved significantly
• High-quality materials: Premium feel
• Excellent build quality: Zero issues
• Zero panel gaps: Precise assembly
• Floating console: Open feel
• Better family SUV: Class-competitive interior

BMW Curved Display & iDrive 9

Single-piece curved glass houses dual displays creating seamless visual integration. 10.25-inch digital instrument cluster provides customizable driver information. 10.7-inch central touchscreen serves as command center^[2]. Crystal clear display quality improves readability under various lighting conditions^[2].

BMW Operating System 9 with QuickSelect debuts on M35i (new for 2024) featuring redesigned home screen for easier navigation^[2]. Enhanced functionality curbs need to sift through submenus streamlining common tasks. “Huge improvement over analogue previous setup” per reviewer consensus^[2]. Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto standard eliminate cable requirements though some owners report connectivity issues.

Touchscreen Controls Controversy

Major criticism centers on lack of physical climate controls forcing touchscreen interaction for temperature adjustments^[2][3]. iDrive rotary knob removed drawing universal complaint from reviewers and owners preferring tactile feedback. “Using touchscreen for climate settings distracting” requiring eyes off road^[2].

Many reviewers and owners “miss physical switches” enabling blind operation^[2]. Some consider iDrive 9 feels like downgrade from iDrive 7 despite enhanced graphics^[2]. Learning curve exists for touchscreen dependency creating frustration during adaptation period. “Frustrating controls” per owner feedback though sleek appearance trades functionality for aesthetics^[2].

Materials & Build Quality

High-quality materials with soft-touch surfaces throughout elevate perceived luxury. Excellent build quality praised with sturdy construction. Attractive trim options including wood finishes provide personalization opportunities. Standard synthetic leather (SensaTec) upholstery delivers premium tactile quality rivaling genuine leather^[2].

Optional premium leather available for buyers preferring traditional materials. Plushness of materials impressive justifying luxury positioning. Premium feel throughout cabin distinguishes X1 from budget competitors. Sturdy construction with zero issues reported by positive reviewers^[2].

Space & Passenger Accommodations

Surprisingly “pretty roomy” despite subcompact classification exceeding segment expectations^[2][3]. Spacious interior compared to rivals with X1 “feels roomier than Audi Q3” per direct comparison^[2]. Generous legroom front and rear accommodates adults comfortably. Ample headroom both rows prevents cramped feeling.

Five-passenger seating capacity suits typical family needs. More space than typical subcompact crossover competing above weight class in interior dimensions. Comfortable for adults all positions during extended journeys. Rear seat legroom measures 37.0 inches providing adequate accommodation^[2].

Cargo Space & Storage

Cargo capacity measures up to 46.8 cubic feet with rear seats folded per BMW specifications^[2]. Behind upright rear seats, 25.6 cubic feet accommodates everyday hauling including groceries and sports equipment. Flexible storage with split-folding seats enabling configuration versatility.

However, less total storage than Mercedes-Benz GLB-Class offering class-leading capacity^[2]. Decent cargo for compact SUV segment remaining competitive with Audi Q3 and Volvo XC40 rivals. Low load floor facilitates easy loading eliminating excessive lifting. For buyers considering BMW’s larger offerings, the BMW X3 provides significantly more space.

Cargo Capacity	BMW X1	Audi Q3	Volvo XC40	Mercedes GLB
Seats Folded	46.8 cu ft	48.0 cu ft	57.5 cu ft	More than X1
Seats Up	25.6 cu ft	23.7 cu ft	20.7 cu ft	Similar
Rear Legroom	37.0 inches	39.1 inches	39.1 inches	More
Front Legroom	40.4 inches	40.0 inches	40.9 inches	Similar

2024 BMW X1 Technology & Features

iDrive 9 Infotainment System

BMW Operating System 9 with QuickSelect debuts on M35i (new for 2024) updating from OS 8 in 2023 base model^[2]. Enhanced visual clarity and system responsiveness improve user experience. Redesigned home screen for easier navigation curbs need sifting through submenus streamlining common tasks^[2].

Touch interface serves as primary input method replacing beloved rotary controller. Voice controls with natural language processing understand conversational commands. My BMW App enables remote vehicle control including climate preconditioning and door lock status. Navigation system standard provides turn-by-turn directions with real-time traffic information^[2].

Wireless Connectivity Features

Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto standard eliminate cable clutter enabling seamless smartphone integration^[2][3]. However, some owners report connectivity issues creating frustration during daily use. CarPlay disconnections reported interrupting navigation during critical moments^[5]. Android Auto dropping problems affect multimedia streaming and navigation functions^[5].

Wi-Fi capability and hotspot functionality advertised though some owners report “no hotspot/eSIM functionality despite advertising” suggesting implementation issues^[5]. Bluetooth connectivity standard provides hands-free calling. Multiple USB ports throughout cabin enable passenger device charging during journeys.

Standard Technology Equipment

BMW Curved Display frameless design creates seamless visual integration. 10.25-inch digital instrument cluster provides customizable driver information. 10.7-inch central touchscreen serves as infotainment command center^[2]. Wireless smartphone integration standard across lineup.

My BMW App connectivity enables remote vehicle access and control from smartphone. Remote vehicle functions include climate preconditioning, door lock verification, and vehicle location tracking. Standard audio system adequate though premium upgrades available. Multiple USB charging ports enable simultaneous device charging^[2].

Optional Technology Upgrades

Premium audio system upgrades enhance sound quality for audiophiles. Enhanced navigation features available through technology packages. 360-degree surround-view camera optional simplifies parking in tight spaces. Head-up display available projects key information onto windshield^[2].

Augmented reality navigation on M35i overlays directions on real-world camera view enhancing situational awareness though some owners report “augmented reality not functioning initially” requiring software updates^[5]. Interior camera for driver monitoring enables advanced safety features. Advanced driver assistance packages expand semi-autonomous capabilities. Enhanced parking assistance systems automate challenging maneuvers.

2024 BMW X1 Safety Features

Excellent Safety Ratings

The 2024 X1 earns IIHS Top Safety Pick+ award representing highest safety designation available^[2][3]. NHTSA awards 4-star overall rating falling one star short of top grade though still strong performance^[2]. Third-generation chassis incorporates advanced safety engineering with crumple zones and reinforced passenger cell.

Excellent safety ratings per AI Overviews highlight strong crash test performance. Multiple airbags provide comprehensive occupant protection. Electronic stability control standard enhances vehicle stability preventing loss of control during emergency maneuvers.

Safety Ratings Summary:

• IIHS: Top Safety Pick+ (highest award)
• NHTSA: 4 stars overall (strong performance)
• Third-gen chassis: Advanced safety engineering
• Multiple airbags: Comprehensive protection
• Stability control: Enhanced vehicle control
• Strong performance: Excellent crash testing

Standard Active Safety Systems

Active Driving Assistant standard all trims provides multi-faceted protection^[2][3]. Blind-spot monitoring standard alerts drivers to vehicles in adjacent lanes. Forward collision warning with automatic emergency braking detects potential impacts applying brakes automatically if driver fails responding. Lane departure warning standard alerts when drifting from lane without signaling.

Speed Limit Information display shows current posted limits. Pedestrian detection capability identifies pedestrians in vehicle path. Active Park Distance Control standard provides audible warnings during parking maneuvers^[2]. Front and rear parking sensors standard comprehensive coverage. Tire Pressure Monitoring System alerts when inflation pressures drop.

Optional Driver Assistance Packages

Enhanced driver assistance features available expand semi-autonomous capabilities. Adaptive cruise control with stop-and-go capability maintains set following distance automatically bringing vehicle to complete stops in congestion. Lane centering assistance optional maintains lane position with gentle steering inputs^[2].

Traffic Jam Assist available provides semi-autonomous operation in congested traffic. 360-degree camera system optional provides comprehensive view during parking. Parking assistance automated features simplify challenging maneuvers. Front cross-traffic alert available monitors for approaching traffic at intersections. Additional safety packages offer expanded protection.

Known Safety Issues & Concerns

Some owners report electronic system malfunctions affecting safety feature operation^[5]. Connectivity issues potentially affect safety features relying on stable connections. CarPlay dropping during navigation represents safety concern when relying on directions^[5]. Infotainment system occasional freezing affects rearview camera display.

Drive recorder/anti-theft issues early production units requiring service intervention^[5]. Augmented reality not working initially (some units) suggesting software calibration problems. Service required for electronic issues under warranty though repairs waste time creating inconvenience.

2024 BMW X1 Reliability & Common Problems

Third-Generation Early Reliability

First full year of third-generation production means limited long-term reliability data available making definitive assessment premature^[6]. Some early production issues emerging create uncertainty. Mixed owner reviews regarding dependability—some report excellent reliability while others experience multiple service visits within first year^[5].

Build quality improvements over previous generations address historical BMW criticism. J.D. Power reliability rating 83 out of 100 for 2022 previous-generation indicated above-average dependability though third-generation ratings not yet available^[6]. Too early for definitive reliability assessment requiring more ownership data accumulation.

M35i Specific Issues Reported

Multiple M35i owners report drivetrain error messages requiring dealer intervention^[5]. VANOS actuators requiring replacement affecting variable valve timing operation. Battery replacement issues reported within first year ownership^[5]. Head unit replacements needed addressing infotainment system failures.

Transmission getting stuck in gears forcing vehicle into limp mode^[5]. High rev in low gears during local driving suggesting calibration issues. Remote start triggering drivetrain errors creating safety concerns^[5]. Multiple M35i owners report similar problems suggesting pattern rather than isolated incidents—one owner documented vehicle sitting at dealership nearly one month awaiting VANOS parts^[5].

Common Electronic Problems

Owners report iDrive 9 laggy and buggy with system responsiveness issues^[5]. Infotainment system freezing and crashes require restart procedure. Android Auto disconnection issues interrupt multimedia streaming^[5]. CarPlay connectivity cutting out during navigation represents safety concern.

No hotspot/eSIM functionality despite advertising frustrates owners expecting advertised features^[5]. Drive recorder installation problems prevent proper security feature operation. Augmented reality not functioning initially requires software updates addressing calibration^[5]. System updates required addressing issues though availability depends on BMW’s development schedule.

Mechanical Issues Reported

VANOS solenoid replacements needed affecting variable valve timing operation^[5]. Drivetrain faults requiring service trigger warning messages and limp mode. Transmission hesitation and rough shifting affect smooth operation. Engine start-stop system rough operation creates jerky behavior^[5].

Can only disable start-stop through touchscreen rather than physical button—system defaults to “ON” every ignition cycle frustrating owners^[5]. Significant lag when stopped requiring finesse managing throttle/brake preventing jerky operation. Turbocharger waste gate issues carried forward from previous generation affecting some units^[6].

Warranty & Service Considerations

Basic warranty covers 4 years / 50,000 miles matching powertrain warranty duration^[6]. Roadside assistance included during warranty period. However, early production units requiring multiple service visits waste considerable time^[5]. Dealer service quality varies significantly by location—some owners report excellent service while others experience frustration.

Some owners pursuing lemon law claims suggesting serious recurring issues^[5]. BMW corporate response inconsistent per forums with some owners receiving satisfactory resolution while others battle bureaucracy. Parts availability affecting repair timelines—one M35i owner waited nearly month for VANOS parts extending service visit significantly^[5].

Long-Term Ownership Concerns

Electronic complexity may cause future issues as vehicle ages and components approach end-of-life. iDrive 9 system still being refined through software updates suggesting ongoing development. Premium fuel requirement increases costs versus mass-market competitors accepting regular unleaded^[6].

Maintenance costs typical for BMW luxury brand reflecting premium positioning. Extended warranty consideration recommended given electronic system complexity potentially causing expensive post-warranty repairs^[6]. Early adopter risks with redesigned model suggest waiting for running changes if reliability concerns significant. According to Autvex automotive experts, buyers should carefully weigh early production risks against desire for latest technology when considering first-year redesigned vehicles.

2024 BMW X1 vs Competitors

BMW X1 vs Mercedes-Benz GLB

Space advantage strongly favors GLB offering more cargo capacity versus X1’s 46.8 cubic feet. Seating capacity win decisively goes to GLB with available third row accommodating 7 passengers versus X1’s five-passenger limitation—critical differentiator for larger families^[2].

Handling dominance belongs to X1 delivering significantly more athletic and engaging dynamics versus comfort-focused GLB prioritizing smooth ride. Interior comparison shows X1 more tech-forward versus GLB’s more traditional approach. Pricing positions vehicles similarly in segment. Value determination depends on priorities—X1 for driving dynamics, GLB for maximum space and seating flexibility. Ride quality shows GLB softer, X1 sportier character.

BMW X1 vs Volvo XC40

Pricing advantage favors Volvo XC40 starting slightly lower than X1’s $38,600 entry point. Safety reputation advantage goes to Volvo with brand’s legendary safety leadership though both offer comprehensive protection. Handling engagement strongly favors X1 providing more enjoyable driving experience for enthusiasts prioritizing dynamics.

Interior design represents different philosophies—Volvo’s Scandinavian minimalism versus BMW’s performance-focused approach—both delivering premium execution with quality materials. Technology offerings both comprehensive and modern representing segment expectations. Space nearly identical passenger and cargo room eliminating utility advantage either direction. Value assessment depends on priorities—XC40 lower entry price and safety reputation, X1 superior driving dynamics and brand prestige.

BMW X1 vs Audi Q3

Direct comparison shows X1 feels roomier than Q3 per reviewer assessment despite similar exterior dimensions^[2]. Handling characteristics favor X1 with more athletic character versus Q3’s composed but less exciting dynamics. Interior technology both modern though different implementation philosophies—Audi Virtual Cockpit versus BMW Curved Display representing competing visions.

Pricing positions vehicles similarly in compact luxury SUV segment. Performance advantage favors X1 offering more powerful M35i option versus Q3’s conservative powertrain choices. Cargo capacity slightly favors X1 with more space behind rear seats. Value assessment shows X1 better standard equipment justifying similar pricing through enhanced features. For deeper comparison, exploring Audi Q5 vs BMW X3 provides cross-segment insights.

BMW X1 vs BMW X3 (Within Brand)

Size advantage X3 with larger dimensions providing more interior space and cargo capacity. Pricing starts significantly higher for X3 reflecting premium positioning within brand hierarchy. Performance similar powertrain options available both models though X3 offers additional engine choices including inline-six.

Handling dynamics both deliver BMW athletic character though X3 benefits from longer wheelbase improving high-speed stability. Fuel economy advantage X1 due to smaller size and lighter weight reducing consumption. Value proposition favors X1 as better entry price for BMW brand enabling ownership at lower cost threshold. Decision framework suggests X1 sufficient for most buyers while X3 necessary only when additional space justifies premium pricing.

Comparison	BMW X1	Mercedes GLB	Volvo XC40	Audi Q3
Starting Price	$38,600	Higher	Slightly lower	Similar
Horsepower	241-312 HP	221 HP	228 HP	228 HP
0-60 mph	5.4-5.6 sec	~7.2 sec	~7.0 sec	~7.1 sec
Cargo (folded)	46.8 cu ft	More	57.5 cu ft	48.0 cu ft
Seating	5 pass	5-7 pass	5 pass	5 pass
Safety Rating	IIHS TSP+	Not rated	Strong	Not rated
Key Advantage	Dynamics	Space/seating	Safety	Tech

2024 BMW X1 Ownership Costs & Value

Purchase Price & Market Positioning

Starting MSRP $38,600-$39,000 for xDrive28i plus approximately $1,000-1,175 destination charge totals around $39,600-40,175 out-the-door before taxes and fees^[1][3]. Performance M35i commands $49,900 MSRP plus destination for approximately $50,900-51,075 total^[4]. First-year pricing for redesigned model reflects premium positioning versus previous generation.

Competitive positioning with luxury compact SUV rivals balances features and pricing. Entry-level BMW SUV positioning makes X1 accessible gateway into brand ownership at manageable pricing versus larger X3 starting significantly higher. Premium reflects enhanced technology, improved interior quality, and expanded powertrain options justifying investment.

Total Cost of Ownership Analysis

Insurance costs typical for luxury SUV segment ranging $1,200-1,800 annually depending on location, driver age, and coverage levels. Premium fuel requirement increases operating expenses approximately $300-500 annually versus regular unleaded depending on driving patterns^[6]. Maintenance costs typical for BMW luxury brand reflecting premium positioning^[6].

Cost to drive estimated $218/month fuel reflecting premium pricing and typical patterns^[3]. Depreciation typical for luxury SUV expecting 15-20% first year decline. Four-year/50,000-mile warranty coverage provides peace of mind during critical ownership period. Parts and labor costs reflect premium positioning commanding higher rates than mainstream brands.

Value Comparison Within Segment

More standard features than many competitors justifying premium pricing through enhanced equipment levels. Excellent safety ratings (IIHS Top Safety Pick+) distinguish X1 as segment leader^[2][3]. Engaging driving dynamics justify premium for enthusiasts prioritizing involvement over anonymous comfort.

Spacious interior compared to segment rivals maximizes utility within compact footprint. Advanced technology standard across lineup eliminates need for expensive option packages. “Best all around pick in its class” per owner review emphasizing comprehensive capability^[5]. Strong value proposition per reviewers balancing performance, features, and pricing competitively.

Resale Value & Depreciation

New generation should hold value better benefiting from modern technology and improved design. Strong BMW brand recognition supports residual values versus less established competitors lacking prestige. First-year redesign depreciation 15-20% expected typical for luxury SUV segment^[6].

M35i may hold value slightly better attracting enthusiast buyers willing paying premium for performance. Compact luxury SUV segment highly competitive affecting all brand values through market saturation. Reliability concerns may affect future resale if electronic issues prove widespread though limited data prevents definitive assessment^[5]. Limited used inventory currently available reflecting first-year production.

Should You Buy the 2024 BMW X1?

Who the 2024 X1 Is Perfect For

Drivers prioritizing engaging handling and dynamics find X1 delivers involvement lacking in bland competitors emphasizing comfort over excitement. Tech-savvy buyers accepting touchscreen controls embrace minimalist cabin design appreciating modern aesthetic. BMW brand enthusiasts seeking entry-level SUV discover accessible gateway into premium marque at $38,600 entry point^[1].

Urban drivers needing compact dimensions benefit from nimble maneuverability enabling easy city parking. Performance enthusiasts wanting M35i power enjoy 312 HP and 5.4-second 0-60 mph thrills^[1]. Buyers valuing excellent safety ratings appreciate IIHS Top Safety Pick+ designation^[2][3]. Those wanting spacious compact luxury SUV benefit from roomy interior exceeding typical subcompact dimensions.

Ideal Buyer Profile:

• Enthusiasts prioritizing handling dynamics
• Tech-savvy accepting touchscreen interface
• BMW brand aspirants seeking entry pricing
• Urban drivers needing compact dimensions
• Performance buyers wanting M35i power
• Safety-conscious valuing IIHS TSP+ rating
• Spacious compact SUV seekers

Who Should Consider Alternatives

Buyers needing third-row seating must consider Mercedes-Benz GLB as X1 accommodates only five passengers eliminating large family option. Those preferring physical climate controls should explore alternatives maintaining traditional layouts avoiding touchscreen dependency frustration^[2].

Drivers wanting softer, more compliant ride discover M Sport suspension too firm for daily comfort preferences^[2][4]. Buyers avoiding premium fuel costs find mass-market competitors accepting regular unleaded more economical. Those concerned about early production reliability may prefer waiting for running changes allowing BMW time addressing initial quality issues^[5]. Families prioritizing maximum cargo space discover Mercedes-Benz GLB provides superior utility. Budget-conscious buyers find Volvo XC40 starts lower though compromising driving dynamics.

Base xDrive28i vs M35i: Which to Buy

Base xDrive28i recommended for most buyers delivering sufficient 241 HP power for daily driving needs without performance penalties. Reviewers specifically note M35i ride “stiff and bouncy on rough roads” compromising daily comfort^[2][4]. Better ride quality in xDrive28i enhances everyday driving versus firm M35i prioritizing ultimate handling sharpness.

The $10,000+ price difference proves hard justifying for marginal performance advantage most drivers won’t exploit in typical commuting^[1][2]. Reviewers note M35i “hardly necessary for most shoppers” given base model’s engaging character^[2]. Performance compromises daily comfort through firmer suspension creating suboptimal all-around package. Base model offers better value proposition balancing performance, comfort, and pricing for typical buyers.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Avoid M Sport suspension unless track driving represents genuine priority rather than aspirational thinking—ride quality suffers excessively for typical buyers. Test drive extensively on rough roads assessing tolerance for firm suspension before committing. Verify all electronic systems function properly testing infotainment, safety features, and climate controls eliminating delivery-day surprises^[5].

Check for outstanding recalls and software updates ensuring vehicle current with BMW’s latest calibrations. Consider waiting for later production units allowing BMW time addressing early production issues through running changes. Test touchscreen controls extensively before buying ensuring comfort with interface eliminating post-purchase frustration^[2]. Avoid early VIN numbers if reliability concerns significant allowing others absorb early adopter risks. Verify hotspot/eSIM functionality works as advertised given owner reports of non-functional features^[5].

Final Verdict & Expert Consensus

Reviewers universally praise redesigned X1 as “huge step up” from previous generation addressing historical criticisms^[2]. IIHS Top Safety Pick+ (highest safety award) distinguishes X1 as segment safety leader^[2][3]. Car and Driver “Editors’ Choice” designation recognizes comprehensive capability^[1]. MotorTrend declares X1 “best-looking” BMW vehicle showcasing successful styling transformation^[2].

Performance M35i represents “probably most fun SUV under $50,000” delivering engaging dynamics^[1][2]. However, “shortcomings in everyday civility noted” regarding firm ride quality^[4]. MotorTrend “holding recommendation until refresh” citing ride quality concerns though acknowledging overall excellence^[4]. Strong competitor against Mercedes GLA, Volvo XC40 establishing X1 as segment benchmark for driving dynamics though compromising daily comfort for performance character.

Key Takeaways

• The 2024 X1 introduces new M35i variant with 312 HP delivering 5.4-second 0-60 mph though $10,000+ premium hard justifying.
• Earns IIHS Top Safety Pick+ (highest award) and NHTSA 4-star rating establishing strong safety credentials for segment.
• Redesigned interior represents “huge step up” with tech-forward design though lacks physical climate controls frustrating traditional buyers.
• M Sport suspension creates “stiff and bouncy” ride compromising daily comfort—base xDrive28i recommended for most buyers.
• Early production reliability concerns including M35i drivetrain errors, VANOS failures, and electronic issues warrant consideration before purchase.
• Base xDrive28i delivers engaging dynamics with 241 HP and 28 MPG combined offering better value than M35i.
• Extended warranty recommended given electronic complexity and early production issues reported by multiple owners requiring service interventions.

FAQs

References

1. Car and Driver. (2024). Tested: 2024 BMW X1 M35i Is Highly Caffeinated. https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a60994996/2024-bmw-x1-m35i-test/
2. MotorTrend. (2024). 2024 BMW X1 M35i Tested: Is a More Powerful X1 Better? https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/2024-bmw-x1-m35i-first-test-review
3. Edmunds. (2025). 2024 BMW X1 Specs & Features. https://www.edmunds.com/bmw/x1/2024/features-specs/
4. Automotive Addicts. (2024). 2024 BMW X1 M35i Review & Test Drive. https://www.automotiveaddicts.com/99549/2024-bmw-x1-m35i-review-test-drive
5. BimmerPost. (2024). 2024 X1 M35i – Issues (Help) – BMW X1 and X2 (U11). https://u11.bimmerpost.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2076704
6. Capital Motor Cars. (2024). BMW X1 Reliability: Performance and Durability Review. https://capitalmotorcars.com/bmw-x1-reliability-performance-durability-review/