You may also like:
BMW shows better overall reliability than Mercedes-Benz according to the latest industry studies. J.D. Power’s 2025 Vehicle Dependability Study ranks BMW at 196 problems per 100 vehicles (PP100) compared to Mercedes’ 243 PP100—a significant 47-point advantage for BMW[1]. Consumer Reports 2025 rankings place BMW 8th overall for predicted reliability, well ahead of Mercedes-Benz[2]. However, Mercedes has lower average annual repair costs ($908 vs BMW’s $968) and a slightly better RepairPal rating[3].
Reliability Ratings Comparison
| Metric | BMW | Mercedes-Benz | Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| J.D. Power VDS 2025 (PP100) | 196[1] | 243[1] | BMW |
| J.D. Power IQS 2025 (PP100) | 196[4] | 210[4] | BMW |
| Consumer Reports 2025 Ranking | 8th[2] | 11th+[2] | BMW |
| RepairPal Rating | 2.5/5.0[3] | 3.0/5.0[5] | Mercedes |
| Annual Repair Cost | $968[3] | $908[5] | Mercedes |
| Avg. Shop Visits/Year | 0.9[3] | 0.7[5] | Mercedes |
| Severe Repair Probability | 15%[3] | 13%[5] | Mercedes |
J.D. Power Dependability Study Results
The J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS) measures problems experienced by original owners of three-year-old vehicles[6]. Lower scores indicate better reliability. The 2025 study, based on 34,175 responses from owners of 2022 model-year vehicles, found the industry average at 202 PP100—the highest problem rate since 2009[6].
How BMW and Mercedes Compare
BMW scored 196 PP100, slightly better than the industry average of 202[1]. Mercedes-Benz scored 243 PP100, significantly worse than average[1]. This 47-point gap represents a substantial reliability advantage for BMW in this study.
Notably, BMW improved from its 2024 score of 206 PP100[4]. J.D. Power particularly noted BMW’s improvement in infotainment system reliability[2]. Mercedes’ problems were spread across most model lines, with infotainment systems, electrical components, and exterior issues like water leaks and wind noise being particularly troublesome[2].
Both German brands outperformed Audi, which scored a concerning 269 PP100—dead last among luxury brands[4].
Consumer Reports Rankings
Consumer Reports’ 2025 Annual Auto Survey provides another perspective on reliability[2].
Brand Rankings
| Rank | Brand | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Subaru | Most reliable brand overall[7] |
| 2 | Lexus | Strong across all models[7] |
| 3 | Toyota | 4 models well above average[7] |
| 7 | Audi | Improved over previous years[7] |
| 8 | BMW | Strong improvement[7] |
| 11+ | Mercedes-Benz | Below average reliability[2] |
Consumer Reports found BMW ranking an impressive 3rd out of 32 car brands in some recent surveys, with Mercedes-Benz placing much lower at 27th[2]. BMW’s stronger showing reflects better performance in key areas including major engine problems, major transmission issues, and in-car electronics[2].
Most and Least Reliable Models
BMW:
The data shows BMW’s electric vehicles have varying reliability, with the i4 sedan outperforming the larger iX SUV significantly[7].
RepairPal: A Mechanic’s Perspective
RepairPal’s ratings reflect real-world repair shop experiences rather than owner surveys[3].
| Metric | BMW | Mercedes-Benz | Industry Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reliability Rating | 2.5/5.0[3] | 3.0/5.0[5] | 3.0/5.0 |
| Brand Ranking | 30th of 32[3] | 27th of 32[5] | — |
| Annual Repair Cost | $968[3] | $908[5] | $652 |
| Shop Visits/Year | 0.9[3] | 0.7[5] | — |
| Severe Repair Probability | 15%[3] | 13%[5] | — |
The RepairPal data shows Mercedes slightly ahead of BMW in mechanical reliability, with fewer shop visits and lower severe repair probability[5]. This contrasts with owner-survey data, likely reflecting repair complexity and specialized tool requirements for BMWs[2].
For more details on BMW ownership costs, see our BMW maintenance cost guide.
Ownership Costs Comparison
Both brands cost significantly more to maintain than the industry average of $652 annually[3].
Annual Maintenance and Repair Costs
| Brand | Annual Cost | 10-Year Total | vs. Industry Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMW | $968[3] | $1,000-$1,700/year[8] | +48% |
| Mercedes-Benz | $908[5] | $900-$1,400/year[8] | +39% |
| Audi | ~$800-$1,300/year[8] | — | — |
| Industry Average | $652[3] | — | — |
Long-term ownership data shows Mercedes costs surpassing $2,000 per year by year 7 and $3,000 per year by year 10[9]. BMW follows a similar trajectory, with older vehicles requiring more expensive repairs as components age[3].
Common Problem Areas
BMW Common Issues:
- Oil leaks from lower engine area (most reported problem)[3]
- Climate control system failures[2]
- Vehicle exterior defects[2]
- Timing chain issues (N20/N26 engines)[3]
Mercedes Common Issues:
- Infotainment system problems[1]
- Electrical component failures[2]
- Water leaks and wind noise[2]
- Complex electronics requiring dealer diagnostics[2]
Long-Term Durability and Lifespan
When it comes to how long these vehicles last, BMW has an edge[10]:
| Metric | BMW | Mercedes-Benz |
|---|---|---|
| Expected Lifespan | 200,000-250,000 miles[10] | 150,000-200,000 miles[10] |
| Average Years of Service | 15+ years[10] | 10-12 years[2] |
| High-Mileage Potential | Inline-six models excel[2] | Diesel models excel[2] |
BMW’s reputation for durability stems from stronger build quality and simpler suspension designs[2]. Mercedes vehicles, particularly older diesels, have achieved exceptional longevity records, but modern models with complex electronics face more challenges[2].
Most Reliable Models from Each Brand
Best BMW Models for Reliability
Based on combined data from multiple sources[2]:
| Model | Notable Strengths |
|---|---|
| BMW i4 | Most reliable BMW per Consumer Reports[7] |
| BMW 530i | $620 annual repair cost (well below brand average)[11] |
| BMW X3 | Scores 85-86/100 reliability[12] |
| BMW 2 Series | Some model years achieved just 88 PP100[2] |
| BMW 3 Series (N52 engine) | Proven long-term durability[2] |
Best Mercedes Models for Reliability
| Model | Notable Strengths |
|---|---|
| Mercedes C-Class | Scores 81/100 reliability[12] |
| Mercedes GLC | Strong reliability scores among SUVs[2] |
| Mercedes E-Class | 74/100 reliability, good value[12] |
For both brands, avoiding air suspension systems and complex technology packages improves reliability significantly[2].
Key Takeaways
- BMW shows better overall reliability than Mercedes-Benz in owner surveys, with 196 vs 243 problems per 100 vehicles in J.D. Power’s 2025 study
- Mercedes has lower annual repair costs ($908 vs $968) and fewer shop visits (0.7 vs 0.9 per year) according to RepairPal
- BMW vehicles typically last longer (200,000-250,000 miles) compared to Mercedes (150,000-200,000 miles) with proper maintenance
- Both brands cost 40-50% more than the industry average to maintain, with costs accelerating after year 7 of ownership
- The most reliable BMW models include the i4, 530i, and X3; Mercedes’ most reliable models include the C-Class and GLC
Frequently Asked Questions
Is BMW or Mercedes more expensive to maintain?
BMW has higher average annual repair costs at $968 compared to Mercedes’ $908[3][5]. Both brands cost significantly more than the industry average of $652. Long-term costs for both brands can exceed $2,000-$3,000 annually after year 7[9]. The gap widens as vehicles age, with both requiring expensive repairs to complex components.
Which lasts longer: BMW or Mercedes?
BMWs typically last 200,000-250,000 miles with an average lifespan of 15+ years, while Mercedes vehicles generally last 150,000-200,000 miles over 10-12 years[10]. BMW’s inline-six engines and simpler suspension designs contribute to better longevity. However, maintenance quality matters more than brand—both can achieve high mileage with proper care[2].
Why do J.D. Power and RepairPal rate these brands differently?
J.D. Power surveys vehicle owners about problems they’ve experienced, capturing everything from minor annoyances to major failures[6]. RepairPal aggregates data from actual repair shops, focusing on repair frequency, cost, and severity[3]. BMW scores better with owners (fewer reported problems) but worse with mechanics (more complex repairs requiring specialized tools)[2].
Which brand has better resale value?
The used market shows BMW offering better value due to steeper depreciation despite slightly better reliability[2]. Three-year-old BMWs typically cost 5-8% less than equivalent Mercedes models. Mercedes’ perceived luxury status helps maintain stronger resale values, though this means higher purchase prices for used buyers[2].
Are German luxury cars less reliable than Japanese brands?
Yes, both BMW and Mercedes rank significantly below Japanese luxury brands in reliability studies[7]. Consumer Reports places Lexus 2nd and Toyota 3rd, while BMW ranks 8th and Mercedes even lower[7]. However, German brands offer performance and driving dynamics that Japanese competitors often don’t match, representing a different value proposition for enthusiast buyers.
References
- Autvex. (2025). What Is More Reliable: BMW or Mercedes? https://autvex.com/webstories/what-is-more-reliable-bmw-or-mercedes/
- BMW Insights. (2025). BMW Vs Mercedes Reliability: Which Is More Dependable? https://bmwinsights.com/bmw-vs-mercedes-reliability/
- RepairPal. (2025). BMW Reliability – 2025 Ratings. https://repairpal.com/reliability/bmw
- BMW Blog. (2025). 2025 J.D. Power Initial Quality Study Puts BMW Below Average. https://www.bmwblog.com/2025/06/29/2025-jd-power-initial-quality-study-bmw-below-average/
- RepairPal. (2025). Mercedes-Benz C300 Repair: Service and Maintenance Cost. https://repairpal.com/mercedes-benz/c300
- J.D. Power. (2025). 2025 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS). https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2025-us-vehicle-dependability-study-vds
- YouTube – Motormouth. (2025). Most and least reliable for each brand // 2025 Consumer Reports. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p8Ti9WZ-_AY
- Foreign Affairs Auto. (2025). BMW vs Mercedes vs Audi | Maintenance Guide for Florida. https://foreignaffairsauto.com/bmw-vs-mercedes-vs-audi-comparative-maintenance-guide-for-florida-drivers/
- YouTube – Car Help Corner. (2024). Most Costly Cars To Maintain & Repair. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XumauStyzBM
- Four Wheel Trends. (2023). Are Mercedes Cars More Reliable Than BMWs? A Comparative Analysis. https://fourwheeltrends.com/are-mercedes-cars-more-reliable-than-bmws/
- RepairPal. (2025). BMW 530i Repair: Service and Maintenance Cost. https://repairpal.com/bmw/530i
- CarPlus UK. (2024). BMW vs Mercedes: Side-by-Side Brand Comparison. https://carplus.co.uk/magazine/bmw-vs-mercedes/
I am a senior automotive analyst at Autvex. Expert vehicle evaluations, in-depth reviews, and objective analysis helping readers make informed automotive decisions with years of industry experience.
